Head-to-head · Email Archiving Software
Email Archiving Software head-to-head
Pick any two of the 27 tools in our email archiving software ranking, or start with the matchups between the top 8. Every comparison uses the same researched facts: editor score, price, free plan and the features that matter in this category.
- 27tools ranked
- 28top matchups
- 351possible pairs
- Oct 2026last re-check
Top matchups The top four, head-to-head
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive Barracuda Message Archiver Proofpoint Enterprise Archive leads on 0 of 4 checks, Barracuda Message Archiver on 0, and 4 are even. Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Barracuda Message Archiver →
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive Mimecast Cloud Archive Proofpoint Enterprise Archive leads on 0 of 3 checks, Mimecast Cloud Archive on 0, and 3 are even. Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Mimecast Cloud Archive →
- Barracuda Message Archiver Mimecast Cloud Archive Barracuda Message Archiver leads on 0 of 4 checks, Mimecast Cloud Archive on 0, and 4 are even. Barracuda Message Archiver vs Mimecast Cloud Archive →
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive Zoho eProtect Proofpoint Enterprise Archive leads on 0 of 3 checks, Zoho eProtect on 0, and 3 are even. Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Zoho eProtect →
- Barracuda Message Archiver Zoho eProtect Barracuda Message Archiver leads on 0 of 4 checks, Zoho eProtect on 0, and 4 are even. Barracuda Message Archiver vs Zoho eProtect →
- Mimecast Cloud Archive Zoho eProtect Mimecast Cloud Archive leads on 0 of 3 checks, Zoho eProtect on 0, and 3 are even. Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Zoho eProtect →
Every top-8 matchup 28 comparisons, grouped by tool
-
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- Proofpoint Enterprise Archive vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- Mimecast Cloud Archive vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- Zoho eProtect vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- Zoho eProtect vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- Zoho eProtect vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- Zoho eProtect vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Zoho eProtect vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Zoho eProtect vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- Zoho eProtect vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- IBM Content Collector for Email vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
- OpenText Retain Unified Archiving vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- Jatheon Cloud vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- Jatheon Cloud vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- Jatheon Cloud vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- Jatheon Cloud vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- Jatheon Cloud vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Jatheon Cloud vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Jatheon Cloud vs Global Relay Archive8.9
-
- Global Relay Archive vs Proofpoint Enterprise Archive9.4
- Global Relay Archive vs Barracuda Message Archiver9.3
- Global Relay Archive vs Mimecast Cloud Archive9.2
- Global Relay Archive vs Zoho eProtect9.1
- Global Relay Archive vs IBM Content Collector for Email9.0
- Global Relay Archive vs OpenText Retain Unified Archiving9.0
- Global Relay Archive vs Jatheon Cloud8.9
More head-to-heads
- Intermedia Archiving vs Intradyn Email Archiving
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Intermedia Archiving
- MailStore Server vs Intradyn Email Archiving
- MailStore Server vs MailArchiva
- Intermedia Archiving vs MailStore Server
- Intermedia Archiving vs MailArchiva
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs MailStore Server
- Barracuda Message Archiver vs Intradyn Email Archiving
The full email archiving software ranking
All 27 tools with scores, prices and filters · updated Oct 2026
Advertiser disclosure: iTechGuides is reader-supported. Vendors can pay for top positions in our rankings and for a place on other products' pages, and we may earn a commission when you click some links. Bought places stand at the number bought; this page and our disclosure say so. Paying vendors may get a fuller, more detailed review from our editors, and that review can change their score. How we rank.
Compiled by iTechGuides Editors · Editorial team · Updated Oct 2026
Last updated · How we research and update