Attendance Management Software head-to-head

Compare any two attendance management software

First tool #1 ADP Time and Attendance · 9.0 #2 Paylocity · 8.2 #3 Time & Attendance by ADP UK · 7.7 #4 Dayforce Scheduling · 7.4 #5 Workforce.com · 7.1 #6 Buddy Punch · 7.0 #7 Jibble · 6.9 #8 ClockShark · 6.7 #9 Homebase · 6.7 #10 TimeClock 365 · 6.6 #11 Connecteam · 6.5 #12 OnTheClock · 6.5 #13 Workyard · 6.4 #14 Fareclock · 6.3 #15 Incentify Time Clock & Attendance · 6.2 #16 ClockRite · 6.1 #17 ShiftFlow · 5.9 #18 ADP WorkForce Suite (formerly WorkForce Software) · 5.8 #19 TimeClick · 5.6 #20 Computime Realtime · 5.5 #21 timeware HRMS Document Management · 5.3 vs Second tool #1 ADP Time and Attendance · 9.0 #2 Paylocity · 8.2 #3 Time & Attendance by ADP UK · 7.7 #4 Dayforce Scheduling · 7.4 #5 Workforce.com · 7.1 #6 Buddy Punch · 7.0 #7 Jibble · 6.9 #8 ClockShark · 6.7 #9 Homebase · 6.7 #10 TimeClock 365 · 6.6 #11 Connecteam · 6.5 #12 OnTheClock · 6.5 #13 Workyard · 6.4 #14 Fareclock · 6.3 #15 Incentify Time Clock & Attendance · 6.2 #16 ClockRite · 6.1 #17 ShiftFlow · 5.9 #18 ADP WorkForce Suite (formerly WorkForce Software) · 5.8 #19 TimeClick · 5.6 #20 Computime Realtime · 5.5 #21 timeware HRMS Document Management · 5.3 Compare

Every tool in the ranking is in the list, #1 to #21.

Top matchups The top four, head-to-head

• ADP Time and Attendance#1 · 9.0 vs Paylocity#2 · 8.2 1 win1 even0 wins ADP Time and Attendance leads on 1 of 2 checks, Paylocity on 0, and 1 are even. Geofenced attendance only on ADP Time and Attendance ADP Time and Attendance vs Paylocity →
• ADP Time and Attendance#1 · 9.0 vs TATime & Attendance by ADP UK#3 · 7.7 0 wins2 even5 wins ADP Time and Attendance leads on 0 of 7 checks, Time & Attendance by ADP UK on 5, and 2 are even. Biometric attendance only on Time & Attendance by ADP UK ADP Time and Attendance vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK →
• Paylocity#2 · 8.2 vs TATime & Attendance by ADP UK#3 · 7.7 0 wins1 even6 wins Paylocity leads on 0 of 7 checks, Time & Attendance by ADP UK on 6, and 1 are even. Biometric attendance only on Time & Attendance by ADP UK Paylocity vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK →
• ADP Time and Attendance#1 · 9.0 vs Dayforce Scheduling#4 · 7.4 0 wins2 even1 win ADP Time and Attendance leads on 0 of 3 checks, Dayforce Scheduling on 1, and 2 are even. Mobile clock-in only on Dayforce Scheduling ADP Time and Attendance vs Dayforce Scheduling →
• Paylocity#2 · 8.2 vs Dayforce Scheduling#4 · 7.4 0 wins1 even2 wins Paylocity leads on 0 of 3 checks, Dayforce Scheduling on 2, and 1 are even. Mobile clock-in only on Dayforce Scheduling Paylocity vs Dayforce Scheduling →
• TATime & Attendance by ADP UK#3 · 7.7 vs Dayforce Scheduling#4 · 7.4 4 wins2 even0 wins Time & Attendance by ADP UK leads on 4 of 6 checks, Dayforce Scheduling on 0, and 2 are even. Biometric attendance only on Time & Attendance by ADP UK Time & Attendance by ADP UK vs Dayforce Scheduling →

Every top-8 matchup 22 comparisons, grouped by tool

• ADP Time and Attendance#1 · 9.0
  • vsADP Time and Attendance vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTAADP Time and Attendance vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsADP Time and Attendance vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsADP Time and Attendance vs Workforce.com7.1
• Paylocity#2 · 8.2
  • vsPaylocity vs ADP Time and Attendance9.0
  • vsTAPaylocity vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsPaylocity vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsPaylocity vs Workforce.com7.1
  • vsPaylocity vs Buddy Punch7.0
  • vsPaylocity vs Jibble6.9
  • vsPaylocity vs ClockShark6.7
• TATime & Attendance by ADP UK#3 · 7.7
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs ADP Time and Attendance9.0
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs Workforce.com7.1
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs Buddy Punch7.0
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs Jibble6.9
  • vsTime & Attendance by ADP UK vs ClockShark6.7
• Dayforce Scheduling#4 · 7.4
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs ADP Time and Attendance9.0
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTADayforce Scheduling vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs Workforce.com7.1
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs Buddy Punch7.0
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs Jibble6.9
  • vsDayforce Scheduling vs ClockShark6.7
• Workforce.com#5 · 7.1
  • vsWorkforce.com vs ADP Time and Attendance9.0
  • vsWorkforce.com vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTAWorkforce.com vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsWorkforce.com vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsWorkforce.com vs Buddy Punch7.0
  • vsWorkforce.com vs Jibble6.9
  • vsWorkforce.com vs ClockShark6.7
• Buddy Punch#6 · 7.0
  • vsBuddy Punch vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTABuddy Punch vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsBuddy Punch vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsBuddy Punch vs Workforce.com7.1
• Jibble#7 · 6.9
  • vsJibble vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTAJibble vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsJibble vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsJibble vs Workforce.com7.1
• ClockShark#8 · 6.7
  • vsClockShark vs Paylocity8.2
  • vsTAClockShark vs Time & Attendance by ADP UK7.7
  • vsClockShark vs Dayforce Scheduling7.4
  • vsClockShark vs Workforce.com7.1

Advertiser disclosure: iTechGuides is reader-supported. We may earn a commission when you click some links. How we rank.

Compiled by iTechGuides Editors · Editorial team · Updated Sep 2026

Last updated 28 Sep 2026 · How we research and update