iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Play Batman: Arkham Asylum before Batman: Arkham City. Asylum is the first installment, released on August 25, 2009, while City is Rocksteady Studios’ follow-up from October 18, 2011. Starting with the earlier game gives you the intended story progression and lets you see how the combat, stealth, investigation and traversal systems expand in the sequel.
If you can buy both on PlayStation 4, Batman: Return to Arkham packages the two games with fully remastered visuals and previously released additional content. Nintendo Switch players can use Batman: Arkham Trilogy, launched on December 1, 2023, which includes Asylum, City, Knight and their previously released downloadable content. Check your region, format and current price before purchasing.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Batman: Arkham Trilogy | $26.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Batman: Arkham City - Game of the Year Edition (Restricted distribution) | $26.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Batman Arkham City (Game of the Year Edition) - Xbox 360 | $28.70 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
Batman Arkham Collection (Standard Edition) (PS4) | $25.95 | Buy on Amazon |
The short answer: start with Arkham Asylum
Batman: Arkham Asylum is the best starting point for most players because it establishes the series’ characters, tone and core game design in a controlled setting. The entire adventure is built around Arkham Asylum, Gotham’s high-security psychiatric hospital. That confinement gives the campaign a clear escalation: you learn how Batman moves, investigates, fights and uses stealth while the threat develops inside one readable location.
Batman: Arkham City is the stronger choice only when your first priority is a larger explorable environment and a broader mix of systems. It takes the foundation of Asylum and moves Batman into Arkham City, a heavily fortified district in Gotham that serves as a maximum-security home for the city’s criminals. The sequel adds a new story, a wider villain ensemble and enhanced melee, stealth, investigative and speed-based challenge gameplay.
#1 Best Overall
- Become Gotham City’s ultimate protector across the iconic Batman: Arkham Trilogy.
- Experience Rocksteady Studios’ critically acclaimed gameplay and AAA original storytelling across all 3 games, PLUS all DLC, in one complete package.
- Some features may require an internet connection and an online subscription.
| Question | Best answer |
|---|---|
| Which game comes first? | Batman: Arkham Asylum, released August 25, 2009. |
| Which game is the sequel? | Batman: Arkham City, released October 18, 2011. |
| Best order for a new player | Asylum, then City. |
| Best single game for a contained, atmospheric campaign | Asylum. |
| Best single game for a larger sandbox and more varied systems | City. |
Is Arkham City a direct sequel to Arkham Asylum?
Yes. DC identifies Arkham Asylum as a Rocksteady action-adventure game released in 2009 for Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and PC. DC’s Arkham City listing identifies the 2011 game as a sequel that builds on Asylum’s atmospheric foundation. Warner Bros. Games likewise describes City as Rocksteady Studios’ 2011 follow-up.
That relationship matters even if each game presents a self-contained adventure. City assumes that the player is moving into a continuing Batman setting rather than encountering the series for the first time. Playing in release order means the setting, character relationships and design ideas arrive in the sequence the developers created them. You can begin with City and understand its immediate objectives, but you will be skipping the documented first chapter and experiencing the earlier game’s more focused design afterward.
Release order and intended progression
| Game | Developer | Original release | Original platforms listed by DC | Role in the series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Batman: Arkham Asylum | Rocksteady Studios | August 25, 2009 | Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PC | First installment |
| Batman: Arkham City | Rocksteady Studios | October 18, 2011 | Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PC | Follow-up and expansion of the foundation |
How the settings change the experience
Arkham Asylum: a concentrated, atmospheric adventure
Asylum confines Batman’s mission to Arkham Asylum. The hospital is not merely a backdrop; it shapes the rhythm of the game. Rooms, corridors and surrounding grounds create a connected but controlled space in which the threat feels immediate. The setting supports a dark, atmospheric tone and makes it easier to understand how each new area relates to the previous one.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsThis concentration is useful for first-time players. You are not asked to learn a huge district, track multiple kinds of activity across a city or decide which distant objective to pursue. The campaign can concentrate on Batman’s investigation of events inside the institution while introducing gadgets, stealth and combat in a deliberate sequence. Players who prefer a clear route through a tightly authored adventure will usually find Asylum easier to read.
Arkham City: a fortified district with more room to roam
City relocates the action to “a heavily fortified sprawling district in the heart of Gotham City,” according to Warner Bros. Games. Warner Bros. also describes Arkham City as the maximum-security home for Gotham’s thugs, gangsters and criminal masterminds. The result is a broader environment than the hospital setting of the first game, with more space for movement between objectives and encounters.
The larger setting changes decision-making. Instead of progressing through one institution’s connected spaces, you operate in a district designed to support exploration, investigation and movement across a wider area. That scale is a major reason to choose City first if your priority is a more expansive sandbox. It also means that some players may find the sequel’s opening less immediately focused than Asylum’s contained setup.
Rank #2
- The Game of the Year Edition includes Harley Quinn's Revenge. Now more dangerous than ever and leading a homicidal gang of her own, she is hell-bent on taking revenge against the Dark Knight.
- Bonus content includes: Catwoman Pack, Robin Bundle Pack, Nightwing Bundle Pack, Arkham City Skins Pack and Challenge Map Pack
- Harley Quinn's Revenge contains over 2 hours of content, new storyline and enemies, play as both Batman and Robin, new environments and new collectables
| Aspect | Arkham Asylum | Arkham City |
|---|---|---|
| Primary setting | Arkham Asylum, a high-security psychiatric hospital | A heavily fortified, sprawling Gotham district |
| Atmosphere | Contained, dark and tightly focused | Broader urban scale with a larger criminal population |
| Exploration emphasis | Connected institutional spaces | More open movement through a district |
| Best fit | Players who value a concentrated campaign | Players who value scale and a wider sandbox |
Combat, stealth, investigation and traversal
Both games are built around Batman using gadgets, stealth and physical combat rather than relying on a conventional shooter structure. The important difference is how much room City gives those ideas to operate. DC describes City as building on Asylum’s foundation with enhanced gameplay, while Warner Bros. specifically lists melee combat, stealth, investigative play and speed-based challenge gameplay.
What Asylum teaches first
Asylum introduces the basic vocabulary of the series in a setting where encounters are easier to contextualize. You learn to approach threats, use Batman’s equipment and read spaces for investigative opportunities while moving through the hospital. Because the environment is contained, the game can emphasize atmosphere and escalation without competing with the demands of a city-scale map.
For a newcomer, that makes Asylum a practical tutorial for the whole series rather than only a first story chapter. You can concentrate on understanding how Batman’s movement, stealth and melee encounters fit together before deciding how to navigate a much larger district.
What City expands
City retains those pillars but presents them in a more varied framework. Warner Bros.’ feature description combines melee combat, stealth, investigation and speed-based challenges, indicating a broader range of activities than a single linear path through an institution. The sequel’s larger environment gives traversal and investigation more spatial importance: getting from one objective to another and choosing how to approach a situation become part of the experience.
This expansion can feel like a natural reward after Asylum. It can also make City a less ideal first lesson for someone who wants every system introduced in the most controlled order. The trade-off is not that one game lacks the series’ identity; it is that City asks you to use more of that identity across a larger space.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Villains and story scope
Arkham Asylum centers Batman’s adventure inside the institution and places the Joker and other Gotham villains at the heart of the conflict. Its enclosed setting allows the villain presence to feel concentrated: the hospital itself and the people controlling or inhabiting it remain central to the unfolding threat.
Rank #3
- The Game of the Year Edition includes Harley Quinn's Revenge. Now more dangerous than ever and leading a homicidal gang of her own, she is hell-bent on taking revenge against the Dark Knight.
- Bonus content includes: Catwoman Pack, Robin Bundle Pack, Nightwing Bundle Pack, Arkham City Skins Pack and Challenge Map Pack
- Download Batman Year One movie from XBOX LIVE
- Harley Quinn's Revenge contains over 2 hours of content, new storyline and enemies, play as both Batman and Robin, new environments and new collectables
Arkham City introduces a new story and a wider villain ensemble. The fortified district is designed as a gathering place for Gotham’s criminal population, so the sequel can draw on a broader collection of antagonists and intersecting threats. That larger roster is part of the sequel’s appeal for players who want a more expansive Batman scenario.
The difference in scope is another reason to preserve the release order. Asylum establishes the series’ tone and its approach to Batman’s rogues before City broadens the stage. Starting with the sequel does not make the first game’s plot impossible to follow, but it reverses the way the series introduces its world and cast.
Which game should different players start with?
Start with Asylum if you are new to the series
- You want the documented first installment and the clearest narrative entry point.
- You prefer a contained hospital setting over a large district.
- You want to learn the core combat, stealth and investigation ideas before dealing with a broader sandbox.
- You value a dark, atmospheric campaign with a strong sense of place.
This is the default recommendation because it aligns story order with the progression of the game systems. It also prevents a common adjustment problem: playing the larger sequel first and then interpreting the earlier title as a reduction in scale.
Recommended Free Tools
Start with City if scale is your overriding priority
- You specifically want a sprawling, fortified Gotham district to explore.
- You are most interested in a wider villain ensemble and a new story with more room for movement between activities.
- You want the combination of melee, stealth, investigation and speed-based challenge gameplay described by Warner Bros. Games.
- You accept that you are skipping the series’ first installment and may later encounter a more contained design in Asylum.
Choosing City first is reasonable when your preferences matter more than chronology. Treat it as a deliberate choice for scale, not as evidence that the games have no meaningful order.
Choose Asylum if atmosphere matters most
The hospital setting gives Asylum a focused identity. Its dark, enclosed spaces and escalating crisis are easier to experience as one sustained adventure. If your ideal Batman game is a concentrated investigation with a strong atmospheric through-line, the first game is the better match even if you normally prefer open environments.
Choose City if you want one game with the broader feature set
If you will play only one, City is the better fit for a player who wants a larger environment and more varied systems. That is an editorial recommendation based on the official descriptions of its setting and features, not a claim about a measured review score, completion time or sales result. Asylum remains the better one-game choice for someone who values focus and atmosphere over breadth.
Rank #4
- Batman Arkham collection brings you the definitive versions of Rocksteady's Arkham trilogy games, including all post-launch content, in one complete collection
- experience two of the most critically acclaimed titles of the last generation - Batman: Arkham Asylum and Batman: Arkham City, with fully remastered and updated visuals
- Complete your experience with the Explosive finale to the Arkham series In Batman: Arkham Knight.
- Become the Batman and utilise a wide range of gadgets and abilities to face off against Gotham's most dangerous villains, facing the ultimate threat against the city that Batman is sworn to protect.
What changes when you play City before Asylum?
The main consequence is structural rather than technical. You will encounter the sequel’s larger environment and expanded feature mix before seeing the more concentrated game that established them. City can still function as an entry point because it presents a new story, but you lose the satisfaction of watching the series move from an institutional setting to a fortified urban district.
Playing out of order may also affect how you perceive design scale. After spending time in City, returning to Asylum means moving from a broad district back into a hospital complex. That is not a flaw in the earlier game; it is the result of playing a 2011 sequel before its 2009 predecessor. If you already know you prefer large maps, you may welcome the change. If you want the series to build outward, use release order.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Collections and platform availability
Return to Arkham on PlayStation 4
PlayStation’s official listing describes Batman: Return to Arkham as a package containing both Arkham Asylum and Arkham City. It advertises fully remastered and updated visuals and includes all previously released additional content. The PlayStation 4 release is listed as October 18, 2016.
This is the most direct option for a PlayStation 4 player who wants the two comparison games together. Confirm that the listing you are viewing is for the correct region and edition, and distinguish the bundle from individual versions before buying.
Arkham Trilogy on Nintendo Switch
Warner Bros. Games and DC announced on December 1, 2023 that Batman: Arkham Trilogy launched on Nintendo Switch. The collection includes Arkham Asylum, Arkham City, Arkham Knight and all previously released downloadable content.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
For a Switch owner, the trilogy provides both games discussed here plus the later main entry. If your immediate goal is only Asylum and City, remember that you are purchasing a three-game collection rather than a two-game bundle. Verify whether you want the additional title and check the physical or digital format available in your region.
| Collection | Platform noted in the official description | Included games | Additional content | Release information |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Batman: Return to Arkham | PlayStation 4 | Arkham Asylum and Arkham City | All previously released additional content | PlayStation listing: October 18, 2016 |
| Batman: Arkham Trilogy | Nintendo Switch | Arkham Asylum, Arkham City and Arkham Knight | All previously released downloadable content | Warner Bros. Games announcement: December 1, 2023 |
Buying checklist before you choose an edition
- Identify your platform. The original DC listings cover Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and PC, while the named collections above cover PlayStation 4 and Nintendo Switch. Do not assume that a collection listed for one platform is available in the same form on another.
- Confirm the game count. Return to Arkham contains the two games in this comparison. Arkham Trilogy also contains Arkham Knight.
- Check what “additional content” means in the listing. The official collection descriptions say that previously released additional content or downloadable content is included, but the exact store presentation can vary by region and format.
- Verify edition and region. Compare physical and digital listings, language information and regional compatibility before checkout.
- Check the current price at the retailer. Prices and stock change, and the official release dates do not establish a current sale price.
A practical play order for a first run
- Begin with Arkham Asylum. Treat it as the introduction to the setting, characters and core systems.
- Complete the main campaign at your own pace. The hospital’s contained layout lets you learn the game without also managing the sequel’s broader district.
- Move to Arkham City. You will recognize the series’ foundation while adapting to the fortified Gotham district and its expanded range of activities.
- Use the collection’s included additional content when it suits your goals. The bundles include previously released content, but you can decide whether to play it alongside the main campaign or afterward based on the ordering options presented in your edition.
- Continue to Arkham Knight only if you own the Switch trilogy. It is included in that collection, but it is not part of the two-game comparison and is not required to understand why Asylum should precede City.
Decision table: pick the game that matches your priority
| Your priority | Start with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Following the intended story order | Arkham Asylum | It is the first installment; City is the follow-up. |
| Learning the series gradually | Arkham Asylum | The contained setting introduces the core ideas before the sequel broadens them. |
| Dark, focused atmosphere | Arkham Asylum | The adventure remains centered on one high-security hospital. |
| Large explorable environment | Arkham City | The action moves to a sprawling fortified Gotham district. |
| More varied systems in one purchase | Arkham City | Warner Bros. highlights melee, stealth, investigation and speed-based challenges. |
| Only one game, with focus preferred | Arkham Asylum | Its design is concentrated and atmospheric. |
| Only one game, with scale preferred | Arkham City | Its setting and feature description emphasize breadth. |
| PlayStation 4 and both games wanted | Return to Arkham | The collection packages Asylum and City together. |
| Nintendo Switch and the full trilogy wanted | Arkham Trilogy | The collection includes Asylum, City and Knight. |
Final recommendation
For nearly everyone, play Batman: Arkham Asylum first and then Batman: Arkham City. The order follows the August 2009 release of the first installment and the October 2011 sequel, preserves the narrative progression and lets the move from a contained hospital to a sprawling fortified district feel like an intentional expansion.
Choose Arkham City first only when its larger world and broader feature mix are more important to you than experiencing the series in sequence. On PlayStation 4, Return to Arkham is the two-game collection to look for; on Nintendo Switch, Arkham Trilogy adds the third main game. In either case, verify the edition, platform, region, format and current price before purchasing.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
