A good NHL backup goalie is ready to play well despite irregular starts, gives the starter useful rest, and provides dependable coverage when the team needs it. The role is not simply a matter of having a strong save percentage: preparation, workload, shot difficulty, and the team’s deployment plan all matter.
Why the backup role is difficult
Unlike a starter who may play frequently, a backup can go many days between starts and then face the speed and pressure of an NHL game with little time to find a rhythm. NHL.com reporting describes that gap as a challenge to timing and feel. Casey DeSmith told NHL.com, “The confidence issue, and if you have a bad one not getting right back in is the hardest part.” Eric Comrie described the difficulty as “finding that game rhythm.” Those comments reflect the players’ roles when the articles were published, not necessarily their current affiliations. NHL.com’s reporting on maintaining game rhythm and confidence
What makes a backup effective
Preparation that carries over to games
Practice can be an imperfect stand-in for a game. Open, uncontested shots may not require the tracking, movement, or decisions a goalie needs when opponents screen, pass across the slot, or create unpredictable rebounds. NHL.com reporting describes ways teams try to make preparation more representative, including traffic, one-timers, competitive drills, video, and feedback from a goalie coach. A backup also needs to avoid building habits around easy practice shots that do not translate to game situations. NHL.com on the mental demands of the backup role
A repeatable technical foundation
Reliable positioning and puck tracking can help a goalie perform when game timing is rusty. Some coaches favor a technically sound, more conservative positional approach for backups, but that is a coaching view, not a rule that every goalie should use the same style. The relevant test is whether the goalie can read plays and execute sound technique under game conditions.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
#1 Best Overall
- GOALIE SET: Specially designed for street hockey with high quality durable materials that offer premium comfort and protection
- ADJUSTABLE STRAPS: Strap in quick and easy with our adjustable strap design that allows for a fitted feel when preparing to dominate the street
- LIGHTWEIGHT BREATHABILITY: Designed with comfort in mind so there is added ventilation to help keep players cool while they defend their crease!
- JR L/XL SET INCLUDES: Leg pads: 26" , catch glove 11", goalie blocker 14"
- NHL HOCKEY OFFICIAL: This goalie set is officially licensed by the National Hockey League for use with official 2 5/8" street hockey balls only and is designed to reduce, not prevent, injury
A mental reset between opportunities
A backup needs a routine that sustains focus without knowing exactly when the next start will come. Carter Hutton told NHL.com that a goalie can build a rhythm through practice, training, and preparation, adding: “Your head controls a lot of that; the way we think and prepare. Do we prepare to succeed or do we prepare to fail?” The quote describes Hutton’s role at the time of publication. NHL.com’s account of preparation and confidence
Useful coverage for the team
A capable second goalie lets a club rest or protect its starter and gives it coverage if that goalie is unavailable. Teams may share starts or split some back-to-backs, but the choice depends on factors such as the two goalies’ relative ability, rest, opponent, travel, schedule, and health. A backup’s contribution therefore includes the flexibility and recovery time provided to the team, not just personal statistics. Seattle Kraken’s overview of goalie workload
Rank #2
- ALL IN ONE SET: This set has all the mini hockey goalie equipment you need to get between the pipes
- INCLUDES: Adjustable goalie mask, (2) leg pads, catch glove, and blocker!
- COMFORTABLE AND SAFE: The soft foam pads and blockers provide ample protection while remaining comfortable and breathable
- GREAT FOR KIDS: This set is perfect for young kids and is recommended for hockey players ages 3-6
- FOR MINI HOCKEY USE: This set is designed and intended for use with foam balls or pucks only
How to judge a backup’s performance
Start by understanding the goalie’s opportunity: check starts and minutes played, then consider shots faced and outcomes such as save percentage and goals-against average. A small sample can swing sharply when only a few goals separate a good-looking stretch from a poor one, so avoid treating a short run as a definitive verdict.
When available, measures such as goals saved above average per 60 minutes or quality-start percentage can add context. A 2025 retrospective study defines goals saved above average relative to a league-average save percentage on the same shot volume, standardized per 60 minutes in its analysis. It also uses a stated rule to classify quality starts. These are the study’s operational definitions, not universal NHL standards. Neither these measures nor standard box-score statistics fully capture shot type, distance, angle, rush chances, pre-shot passes, goalie movement, defensive errors, or the goalie’s read. Pair statistical comparisons with video and team context. Ekhtiari et al., 2025 retrospective cohort study NHL.com on evaluating goalies beyond statistics
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallOutdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware matchRank #3
- COMPLETE SET: This set has everything goalies need to get between the pipes. It includes leg pads, catch glove, and a blocker pad for improved street hockey fun!
- 28" CUSHIONED LEG PADS: Designed with a pre-curved knee, tapered thigh rise, and easy-fasten straps for a fast, comfortable fit for most goalies
- GOALIE CATCH GLOVE: The 12" goalie catch glove is constructed with pro style T-trap webbing and a hand contoured pocket for an exceptional fit and optimal performance
- LIGHTWEIGHT BLOCKER: The high-density, lightweight 14" blocker pad comes with a built-in comfort fit glove for ultimate control in net
- FOR STREET HOCKEY ONLY: This goalie set is only designed for use with official size street hockey balls (2-5/8"), and is designed to reduce, not prevent, injury
- Workload and shot context: Compare results with shots faced and, where possible, their difficulty rather than relying on raw totals alone.
- Readiness after time off: Look for disciplined preparation and repeatable positioning that can carry over when starts are separated.
- Availability and role fit: Consider whether the goalie can cover the starts and schedule situations the team expects, and how much flexibility that provides.
- Team defense: Review the circumstances around chances against; a goalie’s results do not reflect the goalie alone.
How much should a backup play?
There is no single ideal backup workload established by the historical figures available here. In a 2019-era NHL.com analysis, Stanley Cup-winning goalies since 2009 averaged 44 regular-season games; the sample included Matt Murray’s 13 NHL games in 2016 and excluded his 31 AHL games. The same article reported an average of 46 regular-season starts among Cup-winning goalies since Martin Brodeur won in 2003. These historical comparisons describe particular samples and periods; they do not establish an ideal number of starts or prove that a workload causes playoff success. NHL.com’s historical workload analysis
The article also compared four goalies with 70 or more games in the preceding five regular seasons with 22 in the five full seasons before that. Those are period-specific counts from that analysis, not current league totals. Similarly, the Seattle Kraken’s workload article attributed a just-over-11-percent save-percentage reduction for goalies playing both nights of a back-to-back to Eric Tulsky’s 2013 analysis, while noting that later work by Andrew Thomas and Dom Luszczyszyn found a less significant effect. That estimate should not be treated as settled or current consensus. Seattle Kraken’s discussion of back-to-back workload
Quick Recap
Best Value
- ALL IN ONE GRAFFITI SET: This set has all the mini hockey goalie equipment you need to get between the pipes with style and flair!
- COMPLETE SET: This all-in-one kids set includes (1) adjustable goalie mask, (2) leg pads, (1) catch glove, and (1) blocker so kids have all the mini hockey goalie equipment they need
- COMFORTABLE + SAFE: The soft foam pads and blockers provide ample protection while remaining comfortable and breathable
- GREAT FOR KIDS: This set is perfect for young kids and is recommended for hockey players ages 3-6
- FOR MINI HOCKEY USE: This set is designed and intended for use with foam balls or pucks only
Rank #4
- Ice Hockey Goalkeeper Provide 5 Size :18inch 21inch 23inch 24inch 27inch.
- BenKen Sport Ice hockey Goalie Equipment Set Pullable fabric：The Fabric Can be Lifted And Printed Using a Sublimation Printing Process to Ensure No Fading.
- The Goalie Equipment Recommended for Children and Adolescent, Suit For Ages 3 to 16, It Provide Full Protection When Playing Street Hockey.
- 220mm Thick K15 Hard Foam Of Knee/Leg Pads: With Ultra Lightweight Foam Padding,Soft Gasket, Dispersion Pressure.
- Comprehensive protection: The Superbly Materials and Exquisite Production Technology Allow You to Enjoy the Joy of Hockey on The Sports Field and Avoid the Trouble Caused by Accidental Injuries.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
