UKG Marketplace Software head-to-head

Compare any two UKG marketplace software

First tool #1 iCIMS · — #2 First Advantage · — #3 Paradox · — #4 Achievers · 3.0 #5 Awardco Engage · 3.0 #6 bswift · — #7 DailyPay · 4.0 #8 Employee Navigator · 3.0 #9 Benefitfocus · — #10 HireRight · — #11 Phenom Talent Management · — #12 Enboarder · — #13 15Five · 4.0 #14 Payactiv · — #15 DocuSign eSignature · 6.0 #16 Fuel50 Talent Intelligence Platform · 3.0 #17 AbsenceSoft · — #18 PlanSource · — #19 CloudPay Navigator · 4.0 #20 Appcast · — #21 Apploi · — #22 Wisetail · — #23 Businessolver ACA Compliance Suite · — #24 DATABASICS · 4.0 #25 Checkr Tenant · 3.8 vs FA Second tool #1 iCIMS · — #2 First Advantage · — #3 Paradox · — #4 Achievers · 3.0 #5 Awardco Engage · 3.0 #6 bswift · — #7 DailyPay · 4.0 #8 Employee Navigator · 3.0 #9 Benefitfocus · — #10 HireRight · — #11 Phenom Talent Management · — #12 Enboarder · — #13 15Five · 4.0 #14 Payactiv · — #15 DocuSign eSignature · 6.0 #16 Fuel50 Talent Intelligence Platform · 3.0 #17 AbsenceSoft · — #18 PlanSource · — #19 CloudPay Navigator · 4.0 #20 Appcast · — #21 Apploi · — #22 Wisetail · — #23 Businessolver ACA Compliance Suite · — #24 DATABASICS · 4.0 #25 Checkr Tenant · 3.8 Compare

Every tool in the ranking is in the list, #1 to #25.

Top matchups The top four, head-to-head

• iCIMS#1 · — vs FAFirst Advantage#2 · — iCIMS vs First Advantage →
• FAFirst Advantage#2 · — vs Paradox#3 · — 0 wins1 even0 wins First Advantage leads on 0 of 1 checks, Paradox on 0, and 1 are even. First Advantage vs Paradox →
• iCIMS#1 · — vs Achievers#4 · 3.0 0 wins1 even0 wins iCIMS leads on 0 of 1 checks, Achievers on 0, and 1 are even. iCIMS vs Achievers →
• FAFirst Advantage#2 · — vs Achievers#4 · 3.0 0 wins1 even0 wins First Advantage leads on 0 of 1 checks, Achievers on 0, and 1 are even. First Advantage vs Achievers →
• Paradox#3 · — vs Achievers#4 · 3.0 0 wins1 even0 wins Paradox leads on 0 of 1 checks, Achievers on 0, and 1 are even. Paradox vs Achievers →

Every top-8 matchup 25 comparisons, grouped by tool

• iCIMS#1 · —
  • vsFAiCIMS vs First Advantage—
  • vsiCIMS vs Achievers3.0
  • vsiCIMS vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsiCIMS vs bswift—
  • vsiCIMS vs DailyPay4.0
• FAFirst Advantage#2 · —
  • vsFirst Advantage vs iCIMS—
  • vsFirst Advantage vs Paradox—
  • vsFirst Advantage vs Achievers3.0
  • vsFirst Advantage vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsFirst Advantage vs bswift—
  • vsFirst Advantage vs DailyPay4.0
  • vsFirst Advantage vs Employee Navigator3.0
• Paradox#3 · —
  • vsFAParadox vs First Advantage—
  • vsParadox vs Achievers3.0
  • vsParadox vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsParadox vs bswift—
  • vsParadox vs DailyPay4.0
  • vsParadox vs Employee Navigator3.0
• Achievers#4 · 3.0
  • vsAchievers vs iCIMS—
  • vsFAAchievers vs First Advantage—
  • vsAchievers vs Paradox—
  • vsAchievers vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsAchievers vs bswift—
  • vsAchievers vs DailyPay4.0
  • vsAchievers vs Employee Navigator3.0
• Awardco Engage#5 · 3.0
  • vsAwardco Engage vs iCIMS—
  • vsFAAwardco Engage vs First Advantage—
  • vsAwardco Engage vs Paradox—
  • vsAwardco Engage vs Achievers3.0
  • vsAwardco Engage vs bswift—
  • vsAwardco Engage vs DailyPay4.0
  • vsAwardco Engage vs Employee Navigator3.0
• bswift#6 · —
  • vsbswift vs iCIMS—
  • vsFAbswift vs First Advantage—
  • vsbswift vs Paradox—
  • vsbswift vs Achievers3.0
  • vsbswift vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsbswift vs DailyPay4.0
• DailyPay#7 · 4.0
  • vsDailyPay vs iCIMS—
  • vsFADailyPay vs First Advantage—
  • vsDailyPay vs Paradox—
  • vsDailyPay vs Achievers3.0
  • vsDailyPay vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsDailyPay vs bswift—
  • vsDailyPay vs Employee Navigator3.0
• Employee Navigator#8 · 3.0
  • vsFAEmployee Navigator vs First Advantage—
  • vsEmployee Navigator vs Paradox—
  • vsEmployee Navigator vs Achievers3.0
  • vsEmployee Navigator vs Awardco Engage3.0
  • vsEmployee Navigator vs DailyPay4.0

Advertiser disclosure: iTechGuides is reader-supported. We may earn a commission when you click some links. It never changes our verdicts or rankings. How we rank.

Compiled by iTechGuides Editors · Editorial team · Updated Sep 2026