Head-to-head · Church Payroll Software
Payroll Mate vs Shelby Financials Payroll
Payroll Mate leads on 0 checks, Shelby Financials Payroll on 0, and 7 are even. Who comes out ahead on the 7 yes/no, price and count checks where we have data for both products. The editor score weighs everything else too.
Our verdict
- Highest scorePayroll Mate · 9.0/10
Payroll Mate scores higher on our rubric for church payroll software: 9.0 against 8.8 out of 10; our editors rank them #2 and #4.
Payroll Mate is the better fit for churches needing detailed clergy payroll controls. Shelby Financials Payroll is the better fit for established churches using Shelby Financials.
- Payroll Mate fits best
Churches needing detailed clergy payroll controls
- Shelby Financials Payroll fits best
Established churches using Shelby Financials
Advertiser disclosure: iTechGuides is reader-supported. Vendors can pay for top positions in our rankings and for a place on other products' pages, and we may earn a commission when you click some links. Bought places stand at the number bought; this page and our disclosure say so. Paying vendors may get a fuller, more detailed review from our editors, and that review can change their score. How we rank.
Side by side
| Feature | Payroll Mate 9.0/10 Visit ↗ | Shelby Financials Payroll 8.8/10 Visit ↗ |
|---|---|---|
| At a glance | ||
| Editor score | 9.0 | 8.8 |
| Ranking | #2 in Church Payroll Software | #4 in Church Payroll Software |
| Best for | Churches needing detailed clergy payroll controls | Established churches using Shelby Financials |
| Pricing model | Paid | Paid |
| Starting price | — | — |
| Free plan | — | Not checked yet |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Deployment | Desktop | Cloud |
| Platforms | Windows | Web |
| Support | Email, Live chat, Phone, Docs | Email, Phone |
| Integrations | 4 integrations | 1 integrations |
| Built for | Small business, Mid-market | Small business, Mid-market, Enterprise |
| Features Payroll Mate 6/6 · Shelby Financials Payroll 6/6 | ||
| Clergy compensation | ✓ | ✓ |
| Housing allowance | ✓ | ✓ |
| Tax filing support | ✓ | ✓ |
| W-2 and 1099 support | ✓ | ✓ |
| Direct deposit | ✓ | ✓ |
| Payroll reporting | ✓ | ✓ |
| Our review | ||
| Pros |
|
|
| Cons |
|
|
| Our verdict | Payroll Mate is Windows desktop payroll software from Real Business Solutions for small businesses, accounting firms, nonprofits, churches, schools, agricultural employers, and other organizations. For churches, its most relevant focus is… Read the review → |
Shelby Financials Payroll is a web-based payroll module for churches, ministries, nonprofit organizations, and denominational headquarters. It calculates gross wages, taxes, and deductions; manages voluntary deductions and compensation;… Read the review → |
Strengths and trade-offs
Payroll Mate — where it wins
- Handles taxable, nontaxable, and housing allowance earnings
- Prepares Forms 941, 943, 944, 940, W-2, and W-3
- Exports data to QuickBooks, Quicken, Sage 50, and general ledgers
Where it doesn't
- Windows-only desktop software
- Direct deposit and some forms require separately priced options
- 1099-MISC processing is provided through an add-on
Shelby Financials Payroll — where it wins
- Supports clergy compensation and housing allowance categories
- Maintains federal, state, and local tax tables
- Offers electronic filing, direct deposit, and General Ledger integration
Where it doesn't
- Requires an active Shelby Financials subscription
- Payroll Module pricing is available through contact sales
- Requires a minimum term
- Payroll Mate9.0/10 · Paid
A church-focused payroll option for clergy earnings, tax forms, reporting, and accounting exports.
Visit Payroll MateFull verdict → - Shelby Financials Payroll8.8/10 · Pricing on request
A clergy-focused payroll module for churches already using Shelby Financials.
Visit Shelby SystemsFull verdict →
More comparisons
- CarbonHRM vs Payroll Mate
- CarbonHRM vs Shelby Financials Payroll
- Payroll Mate vs ChurchSoftware Payroll
- Payroll Mate vs IconCMO Payroll
- Payroll Mate vs Amplify Accounting
- Payroll Mate vs Storehouse Finance
- Payroll Mate vs Patriot Payroll
- ChurchSoftware Payroll vs Shelby Financials Payroll
All church payroll software comparisons → · Full ranking →
Reviewed by iTechGuides Editors · Editorial team · Updated Nov 2026
Last updated · How we research and update




