iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
For the strongest all-around pirate fantasy, Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag takes the top spot: it pairs a story-led Caribbean adventure with life at sea. The best pick changes with your preferred play style, though. Sea of Thieves is built around shared crew adventures, Sid Meier’s Pirates! puts privateering choices first, and the final two picks lean into LEGO action and puzzle comedy. This is an editorial ranking, not an objective score: it weighs how well each game delivers its particular version of being a pirate, alongside story, solo or crew suitability, and current platform availability.
How this ranking works
Pirate games do not all aim for the same experience. Some are story-driven action adventures; others emphasize sailing with friends, open-ended privateering, licensed comedy, or puzzles. The order below favors a vivid pirate identity, a memorable core experience, and a clear reason to choose each game. Platform listings are included where the official pages establish them; availability can vary by region and edition.
The five best pirate games
1. Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag — best overall story-led pirate adventure
Black Flag earns the top position for combining a Caribbean setting and a defined action-adventure story with the fantasy of commanding a pirate ship. Ubisoft describes the original as a 2013 pirate action-adventure. Its protagonist, Edward Kenway, makes it a strong choice for players who want a central character and narrative rather than a primarily social sandbox.
Ubisoft also has a separate page for Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced, which places Edward Kenway in the Caribbean during the Golden Age of Piracy and lists PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC storefronts. That is a distinct remake listing, not the same edition as the 2013 original. Check the relevant store for the edition and regional availability you want.
#1 Best Overall
- Engage in thrilling naval battles and equip a multitude of powerful weapons as you risk it all for the biggest loot.
- Sail the lawless seas solo, or team up with two friends or other players to partake in shareable contracts and rewards.
- Face cutthroat pirate hunters, deadly sea monsters, unpredictable weather, dangerous rogue waves, supernatural threats, and more as you explore a vast open world.
- Craft and sail up to 10 different ships at launch, each with unique perks to match your own personal playstyle.
- Grow your infamy and unlock resources and opportunities to get riskier contracts and upgrade your equipment.
Ubisoft: Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag · Ubisoft: Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced
2. Sea of Thieves — best for sailing with a crew
Sea of Thieves is an open-world pirate adventure with story-driven Tall Tales. Its appeal is the shared voyage: crews sail, explore, and take on adventures together, making it the natural pick when playing with friends matters more than following a single hero’s plot. It also supports crews across platforms.
Rank #2
- PIRATE YAKUZA ADVENTURE AHOY - Goro Majima, a notorious ex-yakuza suddenly finds himself shipwrecked on a remote island in the Pacific. Unable to remember even his own name, he sets sail in search of clues to his lost memories, accompanied by a boy named Noah who saved his life.
- GET YOUR SHIP TOGETHER - Assemble a one-of-a-kind crew while upgrading your ship as you explore the open sea and forge your legend in the cannon fire of foes, unexpected friendships, and immense riches made along the way.
- KICK ARRSS WITH CREATIVE COMBAT - Dynamically switch between the “Mad Dog” and “Sea Dog” fighting styles to mix-up attacks and deliver explosive combos, juggles, and aerial takedowns that reward your creativity with over-the-top action.
Rare lists the game for Xbox, Windows, PlayStation 5, and Steam. Its Steam page specifically says progress carries among Steam, Microsoft Store, and Xbox One copies; that statement should not be assumed to cover every platform or version combination.
Sea of Thieves official site · Sea of Thieves on Steam
Rank #3
- This Certified Refurbished product is tested and certified to look and work like new. The refurbishing process includes functionality testing, basic cleaning, inspection, and repackaging. The product ships with all relevant accessories, a minimum 90-day warranty, and may arrive in a generic box. Only select sellers who maintain a high performance bar may offer Certified Refurbished products on Amazon.com
- Exploration - Players will explore familiar locations filled with interactive LEGO objects and encounter more than 70 memorable characters
- Combat - The LEGO Caribbean is full of danger! Intense sword fighting moves give the LEGO minifigure a brand new pirate flavor
- Puzzles - Players will need all their pirate cunning to find the hidden LEGO treasures and discover the game's many secrets
- Two-Player Co-op - Players can join a friend or family member in the same room for two-player drop-in/drop-out cooperative action
3. Sid Meier’s Pirates! — best open-ended privateering sandbox
If you would rather shape your own pirate career than follow a tightly defined story, Sid Meier’s Pirates! is the sandbox choice. Steam describes sailing the Caribbean as either a marauder or a privateer in pursuit of riches, with the player choosing their way of life. That freedom gives it a different emphasis from the character-led adventure at the top of the list.
4. LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean — best lighthearted licensed adventure
LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean adapts the Pirates of the Caribbean world as a TT Games action-adventure in LEGO style. It is the pick for players who want a licensed setting and a lighter action-adventure tone rather than a more simulation-minded pirate sandbox. The cited official page establishes the game’s adaptation and style, but does not provide a platform comparison here.
Rank #4
- The whole story - Experience the one piece story from the beginning.
- incredible action - developed by koei tecmo games, the masters of the Musou action genre.
- sweet victory - Take on many enemies in huge battles from memorable moments of the anime.
- destructible environment - destroy buildings and other surrounding elements that get between you and victory.
LEGO: Pirates of the Caribbean
5. The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition — best pirate comedy and puzzles
The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition rounds out the list by treating pirate life as a setting for comedy and puzzle-solving. It is the outlier for readers who want witty pirate storytelling rather than ship-centered action or crew play. Its place reflects that distinctive niche, not a claim that it offers the same kind of adventure as the other four.
The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition on Steam
Best Value
- Create a resource-based economy - Utilize 100+ unique buildings to provide the essential resources for growth. Supply citizens with goods, develop their proficiency, and unlock new tiers of industry.
- Engage in real-time naval battles - Command a fleet to explore and conquer the archipelago. Engage in real-time strategic combat and switch to the tactical map to plan and execute your next raid.
- Conduct diplomacy - Manage dynamic relationships with pirate crews and trading companies. Harbor rivalries and forge alliances while navigating a diplomatic web where no action goes unnoticed.
- Expand your fleet - Construct 8 unique ship classes and customize your fleet’s appearance. Recruit talented captains, hone their skills in battle, and experiment with a variety of combat tactics.
- Undertake missions - Collect bounties or strike trade deals to influence your standing in the Caribbean. Race to fulfill urgent requests and embellish your settlements with exotic rewards.
Which pirate game should you choose?
| Choose | Best fit | What defines it |
|---|---|---|
| Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag | A story-led solo adventure | Caribbean action-adventure centered on Edward Kenway; the original is described by Ubisoft as a 2013 release. |
| Sea of Thieves | Shared voyages with a crew | Open-world adventure with Tall Tales and cross-platform crew play; progress carryover is specifically described for Steam, Microsoft Store, and Xbox One copies. |
| Sid Meier’s Pirates! | Open-ended privateering | Choose a marauder’s or privateer’s life while sailing the Caribbean in search of riches. |
| LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean | A lighter licensed action-adventure | The Pirates of the Caribbean world presented in LEGO style. |
| The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition | Pirate humor and puzzles | A comedy-and-puzzle take on pirate storytelling. |
Bottom line
Start with Black Flag for a story-led Caribbean adventure, choose Sea of Thieves for crew voyages, and pick Sid Meier’s Pirates! for a more open-ended privateer life. LEGO and Monkey Island are the more specialized choices: one for licensed, lighthearted action, the other for pirate comedy and puzzles.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
