iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
For garden watering, a water butt is usually the straightforward choice. A larger rainwater harvesting system is worth considering when you have regular non-potable household demand—such as toilet flushing—and room and budget for a tank, pump, overflow and more involved installation. Neither option guarantees a particular bill saving: the result depends on rainfall, roof area, storage, how much mains water you replace, your tariff and installation costs.
What is the difference?
A water butt is the simplest form of rainwater harvesting: it collects roof runoff from a gutter and downpipe and stores it for outdoor use, especially watering the garden. A larger rainwater harvesting system adds storage and equipment such as a pump and distribution plumbing. Depending on its design, it may supply outdoor taps or non-potable household uses such as toilet flushing.
The key choice is not whether one is universally better. It is whether you need a modest supply for outdoor tasks or want to capture and use rainwater across more of the home.
Recommended Free Tools
Compare the options
| Consideration | Water butt | Larger rainwater harvesting system |
|---|---|---|
| Typical uses | Garden watering and similar outdoor tasks | Outdoor taps and, with suitable design, non-potable uses such as toilet flushing or laundry |
| Equipment | Gutter/downpipe connection, debris filter, stable base, tap and overflow arrangement | Tank, pump and distribution equipment; indoor uses require more careful design |
| Space and installation | Often easier to place beside a downpipe if there is room for a firm, level base | May require substantial tank space, excavation and specialist installation; retrofitting can be difficult |
| Upkeep | Clear the gutter and filter, keep the butt covered and clean it when needed | Maintain the tank, filters, pump and distribution system according to the system designer’s instructions |
| Financial case | Less complex, but storage is limited | More equipment and installation complexity; any mains-water reduction depends on actual use and tariffs |
This is a qualitative comparison, not a like-for-like price or payback calculation. The available guidance does not establish current, comparable costs or a universal saving for either option.
#1 Best Overall
- Function: Rain Barrel cover for outside use helps prevent the accumulation of debris ,keeps the mosquitoes out and doesn’t allow them to lay their eggs in the water.
- Easy to Install: Simply put the fine-meshed net over the water buckets and fix it with the help of the drawstring.
- High Quality: Buckets Mesh Cover is made of high-quality transparent mesh cloth and PE material.resistant for all seasons.Rain Barrel Screen allows the water in,
- Dimensions (Ø): The stretched size is 95 cm.suitable for all rain barrels with a diameter of up to 80 cm. suitable for all rain barrels with a diameter of up to 80 cm.
- Drawstring Design: With practical drawstring, simple and convenient. It can be better connected to a smaller diameter rain barrel to prevent being blown away by the wind.
When a water butt is the better fit
Choose a butt if your main aim is to collect water for the garden and you want a simpler installation. Before buying, check that a suitable downpipe is available and that the ground can support a firm, level stand. A filter helps keep debris out, while a close-fitting lid helps discourage algae and reduces the entry of rain-borne plant-disease spores. The Royal Horticultural Society’s practical advice on collecting, storing and using water also recommends keeping gutters clear.
If one butt does not hold enough, multiple butts can be joined. A pump may help when you need better pressure for a hose. If stored water smells, the RHS advises emptying and cleaning the butt rather than adding chemicals.
Rank #2
- 50-Gallon Capacity: Provides ample storage for harvested rainwater, ideal for watering gardens, lawns, and plants.
- Durable Construction: Made from UV-resistant polyethylene for long-lasting durability and protection from the elements. Made of 100% Recycled plastic.
- Overflow Valve: Built-in overflow valve for managing excess water and the option to connect multiple barrels for increased storage.
- Convenient Spigot: Easy-to-use plastic spigot for quick and efficient water retrieval.
- Low Maintenance: Easy to install and maintain, offering a simple, sustainable solution for homeowners.
When to consider a larger system
A larger system may make sense if there is regular non-potable demand to use the collected water, not just occasional garden watering. Decide which uses you want to serve before discussing tank size or equipment: demand, roof catchment, tank location, overflow destination, pump and distribution all affect the design. Indoor applications need particular care; government guidance on permeable front gardens recommends specialist advice for toilet-flushing systems.
The same guidance cautions that larger systems can be expensive and difficult to retrofit, and that an overflow route to a drain or soakaway is needed. Do not assume an existing home is suitable without checking the site and proposed design.
Rank #3
- 50-Gallon Capacity: Provides ample storage for harvested rainwater, ideal for watering gardens, lawns, and plants.
- Durable Construction: Made from UV-resistant polyethylene to withstand outdoor elements and ensure long-lasting durability.
- Overflow Valve: Built-in overflow valve for managing excess water and the option to connect multiple barrels for increased storage.
- Premium Brass Spigot: Features a high-quality brass spigot for easy, secure, and leak-free water retrieval.
- Low Maintenance: Easy to install and maintain, offering a simple, sustainable solution for homeowners.
For development design in England, the national SuDS standards say to consider rainwater harvesting where non-potable demand and a suitable contributing catchment can provide safe, efficient savings, where landscape irrigation is needed, or where development is in an area identified as seriously water stressed. The standards reference BS EN 16941 for system design; they are not a guarantee that a particular household will save money.
What can harvested rainwater be used for?
Keep harvested roof water separate from drinking-water expectations. The Environment Agency’s 2010 domestic rainwater guide covers uses including garden watering, toilet flushing and laundry, but not drinking, food preparation or personal hygiene. It is useful for understanding the distinction between potable and non-potable uses, not for current prices.
Rank #4
- Cut Household Water Expenses: This foldable PVC rain water collection barrel offers an sustainable way to recycle rainwater captured from gutter downspouts. The collected rainwater works perfectly for garden irrigation, lawn watering and car washing. Statistical data proves that using this water barrel for garden can slash your annual tap water fees by up to 40%, bringing obvious cost savings for every family
- Winter-ready Crackproof PVC Build: The rain barrels to collect rainwater from gutter are constructed with sturdy PVC support frames and corrosion-proof PVC mesh fabric. The special PVC raw material delivers excellent cold resistance, so the water barrel with lid can stay outdoors through frigid winters without performance decline. Compared with rigid traditional rain barrels, our PVC water barrel for garden resists cracking and boasts longer service life for years of outdoor use
- Double Sealing Ring Total Leakproof System: Every spigot and outflow valve equipped on the rain water collection barrel comes paired with two silicone rubber sealing rings. You can mount one ring inside the barrel wall and another outside the wall to form double-sided sealing, thoroughly stopping any water seepage. The top mesh cover of the water barrel with lid filters out fallen leaves, floating debris and dirt, keeping your stored rainwater clean and free of debris
- Collapsible Compact Design For Easy Storage: This foldable rain barrel features a lightweight collapsible structure that greatly reduces its occupied space when not in use. The rain barrels to collect rainwater from gutter can be folded flat effortlessly, allowing you to store the water barrel for garden inside garages, storage closets or utility rooms without taking up much room. When you need to collect rainwater again, quick simple assembly enables repeated long-term use
- Multi-Capacity Optional & Interconnectable Structure: This water barrel with lid provides abundant capacity choices including 50, 66, 100, 132 and 200 Gallon to match different household rainwater storage demands. Simply place the rain water collection barrel under your gutter downspout, then rainwater will flow into the barrel through the top filter mesh. Each foldable PVC rain barrel is pre-fitted with a dedicated outflow valve, which supports linking multiple rain barrels to collect rainwater from gutter in series to expand your total rainwater storage volume.
Will either option lower your water bill?
A household on a water meter may reduce mains-water use if harvested rain actually replaces water it would otherwise draw from the mains. The size of any bill effect depends on local rainfall, roof catchment, storage capacity, household demand, the metered tariff and system costs. Government guidance notes potential bill savings for metered use, but does not support a fixed saving or payback period for every home. Treat any estimate as specific to the property and system, not as a typical result.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteRules to check before installation
The Environment Agency’s regulatory position statement applies to England. It defines harvested rainwater as water collected from roofs or other above-ground surfaces through above-ground pipes and tanks, isolated from inland waters or groundwater. In the circumstances it describes, a water abstraction licence is not needed for water consisting only of harvested rainwater.
Best Value
- 【 Well-designed 】 Full path, large flow, no limited flow trouble, this is a good choice. Heavy structural design, durable, beautiful and delicate appearance, 1/4 turn stainless steel large metal handle, easy to switch, long service life.
- 【Easy to install】 Bulkhead joints require 1-1.1inch diameter holes to install and have a maximum service thickness of 0.38 inch (the wall thickness of plastic drums is usually 0.1-0.2 inch), which is suitable for almost all thicknesses of drums. Note: We have a complimentary auxiliary towing rope, which can be easily installed without entering the container.
- 【High quality】quarter turn solid 304 stainless steel ball valve, smooth rotation, no water leakage. Solid 304 stainless steel bulkhead fittings with internal thread 1/2" npt at both ends and mounting bushing at both ends. We provide you with all kits without the need to purchase additional kits.
- 【High quality material】 The barrel spigot material is made of solid 304 stainless steel, lead-free, stronger than brass material, more freeze-proof, leak-proof, suitable for outdoor use.
- 【Packing】: 1 Bulkhead Fitting , 2 leakproof washers, 1 faucet, 1 garden hose quick connector, 1 installation rope, 2 silicone garden washers, 1 threaded tape.
A licence may be needed if a reservoir system combines harvested rainwater with water from sources such as a watercourse, land drainage or underground strata and discharges to inland waters. For mixed-source or unusual arrangements, or if you live outside England, check the relevant authority’s current requirements rather than assuming this England-specific position applies.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
