iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
For cooking over a real fire, the choice mostly comes down to two things: the material (cast iron or stainless steel) and how much weight you can carry. Lodge’s Wanderlust Set is a cast-iron kit that Lodge lists as compatible with a campfire, but its listed weight points it toward car camping and camp kitchens where weight is acceptable. Primus’s CampFire Cookset is a stainless-steel, nesting set that is far lighter and suits trips where you carry your gear. Neither is a universal best. The comparison below is based on manufacturer product listings and general campfire-cooking guidance, not on side-by-side cooking tests.
Start with your trip style
The right set depends less on brand than on how you travel and what you plan to cook.
- Car camping or a fixed camp kitchen: Cast iron is practical. Pack weight matters less when the gear rides in the vehicle, so the heavier, multi-piece Lodge format is a reasonable fit.
- Short walk-ins or trips where you carry everything: Stainless steel makes more sense. The Primus set is listed at about 3.6 lb, which is far easier to shoulder than the Lodge set.
- Stews, baking or feeding a group: Look at Dutch oven capacity and the suspension gear that goes with it, not just the skillet and pot count. The section on Dutch ovens below covers this.
- Beginners: Start with a small set and simple meals. Campfire heat is less controllable than a stove, so a compact kit you can practise with is more useful than a large one you cannot manage.
The sets side by side
The table lists the values each maker publishes. Where a listing does not state a detail, the cell says so rather than filling the gap.
| Feature | Lodge Wanderlust Set | Primus CampFire Cookset Stainless Steel Large | Camp Chef 6-Piece Cast Iron Set |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maker-stated fire use | Lodge says it is compatible with a campfire (Lodge product listing) | Open-fire or camp-stove use (Primus Equipment US product listing) | Not stated in the listing reviewed |
| Material | Cast iron | 18/8 stainless steel | Cast iron |
| Pieces | Three: 8-inch tent skillet, 10.25-inch dual-handle camper pan, 3.2-quart Cabin Combo Cooker | Three: 3 L pot, 1.8 L saucepan, 21 cm frying pan | Legless Dutch oven with trivet, 10-inch skillet, deep skillet whose matching lid doubles as a skillet |
| Listed weight | 23.57 lb | 1,650 g (about 3.6 lb) for the whole set | Not stated in the listing reviewed |
| Storage | Not stated in the listing reviewed | Folding handles; pieces nest for storage | Not stated in the listing reviewed |
| Availability when checked | Listed with a sale price when checked | Not stated in the listing reviewed | Showed sold out when checked |
| Best fit | Car camping and group cooking where weight is acceptable | Lighter loads and stowable kit | Dutch-oven cooking for readers who want cast iron, once the set is back in stock |
The two named sets are not configured alike. The Lodge pieces are cast iron and include a 3.2-quart combo cooker, while the Primus pieces are stainless steel and include a 3-litre pot. The weight gap therefore reflects both material and layout, so it should be read as a trip-planning figure rather than a controlled performance comparison.
#1 Best Overall
- Cast Iron Cookware Set: Includes Dutch oven, griddle, saucepot, skillet, lids, lifter, and box; this full camping cooking set gives you everything needed to prep meals over fire, grill, or stove
- Built Tough for Outdoor Heat: This cast iron camping cookware set handles open flames and high temps without warping; dependable for fire pits, grills, and cabins when you need tools that lasts
- Seasoned and Ready to Go: Arrives pre-seasoned for use instant use; each piece in this camping cookware set saves time at camp while bringing you delicious results in your outdoor cooking every time
- Even Heat for Better Flavor: This camping cookware set distributes heat evenly to fry, bake, or sauté; perfect for making golden pancakes, roasted veggies, or stews in your outdoor cooking setup
- Ready for Every Meal: Fits neatly in your car or pack; this campfire cooking equipment gives you cast iron skillets that cook evenly, store easily, and travel with you wherever your meals take you
The sets in more detail
Lodge Wanderlust Set
This is the set to consider if you want cast iron and do not mind carrying it. Its three pieces cover a small skillet for quick meals, a larger dual-handle camper pan for bigger batches, and a combo cooker that can handle one-pot dishes. Lodge’s campfire compatibility statement is the reason it appears here; the maker states it for this named set, so it is a clearer starting point than a generic camp kit with no fire-use wording.
Primus CampFire Cookset Stainless Steel Large
This is the set for readers who need a pot, a saucepan and a frying pan without the bulk. The 18/8 stainless steel construction, folding handles and nesting design are the features that matter for packing. Primus describes the set for open-fire or camp-stove use, so it fits readers who want one kit for both cooking styles. The listing does not describe handle temperatures over a fire, so check the instructions that come with the set before placing it directly on coals.
Rank #2
- Complete 5-Piece Cooking Set: The Lodge Cast Iron Set includes an 8-inch cast iron skillet, 10.25-inch cast iron skillet, 10.5-inch cast iron griddle, and 5-quart cast iron dutch oven with lid
- Time-Tested Even Heat Distribution: This durable cast iron cookware supports uniform cooking, helping reduce hot spots while maintaining heat for consistent results
- Indoor & Outdoor Versatility: This cast iron cookware performs across stovetops, ovens, grills, and campfires, making it ideal for indoor and outdoor cooking
- Traditionally Crafted Non-Toxic Finish: Made with only iron and oil, this PFAS-free cookware makes dependable, chemical-free cooking easy
- About Lodge Cast Iron: Lodge seasoned cast iron cookware is versatile and as easy to clean as it is to cook with; taste a difference in your cooking with cast iron
Camp Chef 6-Piece Cast Iron Set
Camp Chef’s set is a cast-iron alternative for readers who want Dutch-oven cooking and a range of skillets. Its listing did not state a fire-use claim or weight in the material reviewed, and it showed sold out when checked. Treat it as a candidate to verify rather than a confirmed fit for open-fire use, and confirm stock and fire-use guidance before buying.
Cast iron or stainless steel over a fire?
- Weight: Cast iron is the heavier option in these examples. If you walk into camp, stainless steel reduces load considerably.
- Piece count and function: The Lodge set offers a larger range of cast-iron cooking surfaces. The Primus set covers pot, saucepan and pan with less bulk.
- Packing: The Primus set nests, which matters more in a crowded pack or vehicle box than the piece count suggests.
- Handling: Check handle design on any material. Lodge’s listing does not describe its handle arrangement beyond the dual-handle camper pan, so handle with tools in any case.
Check fire compatibility before you buy
Use this order when evaluating any set, including the two above:
Rank #3
- Constructed from premium cast iron, this black dutch oven pot with lid delivers superior heat retention and distribution for consistent, even heating throughout both the bottom and sidewalls. This enables energy-efficient outdoor cooking while the durable, non-toxic finish withstands rigorous camp use
- This large dutch oven pot with lid incorporates heat-resistant spiral handles and a specialized lid lifter for maximum safety during operation. The reinforced hook attachments provide stable transport capability even at elevated temperatures
- Designed for versatile deployment, this cast iron dutch oven functions seamlessly on a tripod, over open flames, charcoal beds, or conventional camp stoves.
- This cast iron pot requires pre seasoning treatment before use, A well-seasoned surface develops a natural, non-stick patina over time, enhancing cooking performance and ensuring long-lasting durability for all your outdoor adventures.If you do notice rust simply scour the affected area with steel wool, rinse, dry, and rub with vegetable oil
- If you do notice rust simply scour the affected area with steel wool, rinse, dry, and rub with vegetable oil
- Confirm that the manufacturer says the item is intended for campfire or open-fire use. Do not assume that a camping set or a coated household pan is fire-safe.
- Inspect the whole item, including handle grips, knobs and fittings, for rubber, silicone or plastic. Outdoor Life’s campfire-cooking guide warns that these parts can melt at campfire temperatures.
- Decide whether the cookware will sit directly in the fire or be suspended over it. Lodge says its seasoned Camp Dutch Ovens are designed for both, with suspension using a camp tripod or its Fire and Cook Stand.
- Use hot-cookware handling tools at all times, and follow the product’s own instructions for placement.
Dutch ovens and suspension gear
A camp Dutch oven is the most flexible piece for stews, baked dishes and meals for several people. Lodge’s guidance says it can be used directly in a fire or suspended over one with an appropriate tripod. Lodge names three accessories that connect to this use: the Lodge Camp Dutch Oven, the Adjustable Camp Tripod, and the 4-in-1 Camp Dutch Oven Tool. If you plan to hang a pot over the fire, buy the tripod and tool at the same time as the oven so the setup matches the pot.
What are the best camping meals to cook over an open fire?
Outdoor Life recommends that beginners start with simpler meals, because heat from a campfire is harder to regulate than heat from a stove. Foods that need fine temperature control are more challenging. One-pot dishes, such as stews cooked in a Dutch oven, are a practical starting point, since they tolerate uneven heat and can be adjusted by moving the pot.
Rank #4
- 【Lifetime Durability】Dutch oven,well known as a lifetime pot,it is made of high-quality cast iron which makes it robust to indestructible,your dutch oven set will last a lifetime if cared for properly!Eco-friendly materials are non-toxic and pollution-free,the surface is coated with specialized electrophoretic chip resistant coating to offer enjoyable cooking without safety worries,food can be directly placed on the grill,even under high temperature,it will not produce hazardous substances
- 【8 Piece Dutch Oven Cooking Set】The 8-piece camping cookware set has kitchen utensils for each meal:1x4.5qt dutch oven pot;1x2.1qt saucepot;1x 20.4"L x 9.3"W cast iron griddle pan with heat grooves and raised edge;1x 16.7" lid and pot lifter to easily open the lid or carry the cookware from fire to serving area safely;1x 5.3" dia. dutch oven stand to act as pot stand and lid holder,also act as an additional cooking surface;1x5.3" dia. Pan;1x 11.6" dia. flying pan;1xwooden carrying storage box
- 【4.5qt Dutch Oven Pot】4.5 quarts casserole pot is large enough for all of your camp’s cooking needs,suitable for 5-7 people.Equipped with a tight-fitting lid with extra-high brim that allows holding coals on the top for firing from above.Thanks to the tight-fitting lid,the oudoor camping dutch oven pot can better collect heat and accelerate cooking effectively.The spiral stainless steel wire handle effectively prevents heat from transferring to the handle,protect your hands from being burned!
- 【Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Dutch Oven】We’ve done the pre-seasoning work,you can start cooking directly!The dutch oven cooking set features superior heat distribution and heat retention thanks to the sturdy cast iron,make it particularly suitable for cooking and baking outdoors!It is ideal for stewing,simmering,roasting,frying,braising delicious meal directly over an open fire or a campfire or with burning ash,you aslo can use the dutch oven as real ovens to make cookiesbread,pizza and even cakes
- 【Perfect Outdoor Experience】Making camping cooking easier and more enjoyable than ever before with the 8-piece cast iron dutch oven cooking equipment when you're outdoors!This is perfect gift for outdoor enthusiasts and people who enjoy camping,RV lifestyle,hiking,fishing,hunting,camp fire cooking and outdoor cooking!The cookware set is also ideal for home cook who discover the allure of cast iron;for the guy with a penchant for cooking;for the grandmother who would like to go back to nature
Check prices and stock on the day you buy
Prices, sale labels, stock and product configurations change. The Lodge listing showed a sale price when checked, and the Camp Chef listing showed sold out. Neither status should be treated as lasting. Outdoor Life’s guide dates from about four years ago, so use it for general material and cooking considerations, and confirm current fire-use guidance on each manufacturer’s product page before purchase.
Choosing between the two named sets
Choose the Lodge Wanderlust Set when weight is acceptable and you want cast iron for car camping or a group camp kitchen. Choose the Primus CampFire Cookset when you carry your gear and want stainless steel that nests for storage. In both cases, confirm the fire-use statement and inspect the whole item before you light a fire.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- ◈MUST-HAVE SKILLET SET◈ This set includes one griddle, one skillet, and one dutch oven
- ◈QUALITY CAST IRON◈ Crafted from durable cast iron material
- ◈OVEN SAFE◈ Cook in the oven up to 450 degrees
- Included components: One 10.25 In. Dutch Oven with Lid
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
