iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
A patent can give an inventor a right to exclude others from specified uses of an invention, but it does not guarantee commercial success or make enforcement straightforward. In IT Nightmares #008: The Patent Trap, ChannelPro describes Nathaniel Smith’s yearslong effort to defend a mobile-payment invention. The episode is a cautionary story for managed service providers (MSPs) developing software or services: think carefully about protection and disclosure before bringing an idea to market.
What is the story behind “The Patent Trap”?
ChannelPro’s episode description presents Smith’s experience as a yearslong struggle to defend a mobile-payment invention against much larger technology companies. Its summary does not identify the companies, patent numbers, lawsuits, rulings, or costs, so it does not provide enough detail to independently assess the dispute or establish infringement or misconduct. Treat it as Smith’s account as summarized by ChannelPro, not as a court finding. Read the episode description at ChannelPro.
The episode’s broader lesson for MSPs is about preparation. If your business is building proprietary software or services, consider what you may need to protect, what you plan to disclose, and how you would manage the costs and effort of pursuing rights. A patent is one possible tool, not a substitute for a business plan or a guarantee that a dispute will be easy to resolve.
Recommended Free Tools
What does a patent actually provide?
A U.S. patent grants specified rights to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale, selling, or importing the patented invention in the United States, subject to the patent’s scope and applicable law. It does not itself establish that a product will succeed commercially, that another party has infringed, or that enforcing the right will be simple. The USPTO’s patent essentials guide distinguishes the available patent types and explains the rights and terms associated with them.
#1 Best Overall
Patent types and terms are not interchangeable
- Utility patents cover qualifying useful processes, machines, articles of manufacture, compositions of matter, and improvements.
- Design patents concern qualifying ornamental designs for articles of manufacture.
- Plant patents concern qualifying new and distinct plant varieties.
Utility and plant patents may last up to 20 years from the relevant nonprovisional filing date, subject to applicable rules and maintenance fees. That term should not be assumed for design patents or patents in other countries.
What does a provisional patent application do—and not do?
A U.S. provisional application is an initial filing that may establish an early filing date for claims in a later-filed application, but only to the extent the provisional disclosure supports those claims. It is not examined, does not become a patent by itself, and automatically expires after 12 months. To seek the benefit of the provisional filing, an inventor generally must file a corresponding nonprovisional application within that period. The USPTO’s application guidance explains provisional filings and the follow-up requirements.
The practical implication is that “filed a provisional” is not the same as “secured a patent.” The later application must be filed on time, and the initial disclosure must adequately describe the subject matter for which an earlier date is sought. A deadline calendar and qualified guidance matter; a provisional filing does not remove the need to make those decisions.
What should an MSP consider before disclosing or commercializing an invention?
There is no single filing choice that fits every software or service idea. Before making a decision, an MSP can assess the factors that affect both the value of protection and the ability to pursue it:
- Commercial value: How central is the invention to the business, and what would be at stake if competitors could use it?
- Disclosure plans: When and where will the idea be shared—with customers, vendors, investors, or the public? Consider the consequences of disclosure before it happens.
- Disclosure quality: Can the invention be described completely enough to support the scope of protection the business may later seek?
- Costs and resources: Can the business budget for preparing and pursuing an application, as well as for any later enforcement effort?
- Jurisdiction: Where does the business expect to operate or need protection? U.S. patent rights do not automatically provide rights in other countries.
- Time limits: If using a provisional application, who is responsible for tracking its 12-month deadline and coordinating the next filing?
These are planning considerations, not individualized legal advice. Patent applications are complex legal documents; the USPTO recommends consulting a registered patent practitioner. See the USPTO’s guidance on applying for patents.
Where can cost-sensitive inventors seek help?
The USPTO’s Patent Pro Bono Program is a nationwide network of regional programs that may match qualifying financially underresourced inventors and small businesses with volunteer patent professionals. Eligibility and local coverage vary, so check the program’s current requirements and regional availability through the USPTO patent application guidance.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Why having patent rights does not end the problem
A granted patent defines rights; it does not enforce them automatically. An owner may still face the practical challenge of determining whether another party’s conduct falls within the patent’s claims and deciding whether the expense and uncertainty of pursuing a remedy are justified. That gap between having rights on paper and being able to protect them is the caution reflected in ChannelPro’s episode description. The available summary does not establish the legal outcome of Smith’s dispute, so it should not be read as proof that any named or unnamed company infringed a patent.
Quick Recap
Best Value
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
