Recommended Free Tools
iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The available case reporting does not identify an IBM chemical-suit plaintiff who died at 63. The headline cannot be tied confidently to a specific person or lawsuit. IBM faced several distinct cases over alleged chemical exposure at its manufacturing facilities, and reports of deaths in those cases do not establish that any particular plaintiff died at that age or that workplace exposure caused the death.
What is known about the “plaintiff who died at 63”?
No named plaintiff in the documented cases can be matched reliably to the age-63 detail. A 1998 Reuters report, also carried by the Los Angeles Times, described five former IBM employees as having died of cancer in connection with a California wrongful-death suit. It did not identify them as the person in the headline or give their ages. The available information therefore does not establish who died at 63, or even that the age refers to one of those five people.
That distinction matters: reports that a person died after working at IBM, or that a lawsuit alleged chemical exposure, are not proof that exposure caused the illness or death. IBM disputed the allegations.
What were the IBM chemical-exposure cases about?
Workers and family members brought lawsuits alleging exposure to industrial chemicals used in semiconductor, hard-disk, and clean-room operations at IBM facilities, including East Fishkill, New York, and San Jose, California. Chemicals cited in the allegations included trichloroethylene, sulfuric acid, benzene, acetone, xylene, and formaldehyde. The cases raised different claims, including cancer, wrongful death, and birth defects; they were not one lawsuit with one outcome.
#1 Best Overall
- Complete Full-Body Protection: Andes Safety Chemical Protection Coveralls feature sealed seams, an attached hood, and integrated boot covers for full-body protection. Constructed from reinforced polyethylene-coated fabric for enhanced durability
- Chemical and Particle Resistance: Engineered to provide reliable coverage against light chemicals and particles, it helps protect against many acids, alkalis, and petroleum-based substances
- Anti-Static Fabric: Anti-static treated to reduce the risk of ignition in flammable environments and suitable for cleanroom, pharmaceutical, and controlled contamination settings
- Multi-Purpose Industrial Use: Suitable for chemical handling, industrial cleaning, oil and gas operations, food processing, and laboratory work applications
- Enhanced Worker Visibility: Bright yellow coverall improves worker visibility in low-light or high-risk environments
Los Angeles Times reporting in 2001 described more than 220 IBM employees and family members as involved in related semiconductor-plant litigation. That figure describes the broader litigation reported at the time, not a count of plaintiffs in a single case.
How did the major cases end?
| Case or parties | Facility and claim | Outcome and what it established |
|---|---|---|
| William Pfleging and his family | Pfleging worked at IBM’s East Fishkill facility from 1973 to 1976. His daughter Alyssa, born December 24, 1974, had severe congenital limb deformities. The family alleged a connection to workplace chemical exposure. | New York courts dismissed the claims as time-barred. That procedural ruling did not establish whether exposure caused the birth defects. |
| Michael Ruffing and Faye Carlton | Former East Fishkill employees who brought a case over their son’s birth defects. | IBM settled in January 2001. The terms were not disclosed, and IBM admitted no liability. The Los Angeles Times reported the settlement. |
| Candace Curtis | A separate case involving alleged workplace-related injuries. | IBM settled in March 2004 on confidential terms. IBM spokesman Christopher Andrews said the company believed it had no liability and that its workplace did not cause the injuries, according to the Los Angeles Times. |
| Alida Hernandez and James Moore | California cancer claims against IBM. | A California jury found IBM not liable. After mediation, about 100 California IBM chemical cases were dismissed, EE Times reported in 2004. |
| Russell Woron | His New York case alleged exposure at East Fishkill. He was diagnosed with multiple myeloma in September 1997. | An appellate court affirmed dismissal as time-barred. The ruling addressed the filing deadline, not whether the alleged exposure caused his illness. |
In 2004, EE Times also reported that about 110 cancer and birth-defect cases remained pending in Westchester County, New York. That was a report of the cases’ status at that time, not a statement of their eventual outcomes.
Rank #2
- The Microporous PE Film Coverall, designed to provide unparalleled protection, comfort, and durability.
- The 4-thread overlock stitch can result in stronger seam, reducing the risk of tears or breakages.
- Fabric with anti-static feature helps to prevent the buildup of static electricity during use.
- Andes disposable protective coverall provides protection from dry particulates such as dirt, dust, and paint.
- Heavy-duty disposable coverall features an integrated hood with elastic wrists and ankles for a secure fit and full-body coverage during painting and other demanding work applications.
Did IBM settle the cases or admit responsibility?
Some cases settled, but the settlements described in the available reports do not establish IBM’s liability. The 2001 Ruffing-Carlton settlement had undisclosed terms, and IBM admitted no liability; the terms of the 2004 Curtis settlement were also confidential. Other outcomes differed: a California jury found IBM not liable in the Hernandez and Moore cancer cases, while New York courts dismissed the Pfleging and Woron claims as time-barred.
These are legally different results. A settlement ends a dispute without necessarily deciding who was responsible. A defense verdict means the jury found for IBM in the cases it heard. A time-bar dismissal rests on a filing deadline rather than a finding about the underlying exposure allegations.
Rank #3
- The Microporous PE Film Coverall, designed to provide unparalleled protection, comfort, and durability.
- The 4-thread overlock stitch can result in stronger seam, reducing the risk of tears or breakages.
- Fabric with anti-static feature helps to prevent the buildup of static electricity during use.
- Andes disposable protective coverall provides protection from dry particulates such as dirt, dust, and paint.
- Heavy-duty disposable coverall features an integrated hood with elastic wrists and ankles for a secure fit and full-body coverage during painting and other demanding work applications.
What can be concluded about the death?
The documented litigation shows that former IBM workers and their families alleged serious harms, including cancers, deaths, and birth defects, and that outcomes varied across cases. It does not identify a plaintiff who died at 63. Without a case-specific obituary, court record, or report connecting that age to a named litigant, naming someone would risk conflating separate cases and presenting an unverified detail as fact.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Combines resistance to low-concentration, water-based, inorganic chemicals with the strength and durability of Tyvek
- Chemical protective clothing, category III, Type 3-b, 4-b, 5-b and 6-b
- Protection against infective agents including resistance to penetration by blood, body fluids and Blood-Borne pathogens
- Fabric and seams offer chemical permeation barrier to low concentration water-based inorganic chemicals
- Serged and over-taped seams for protection and strength
Rank #4
- Comprehensive Full-Body Protection: Andes Safety Chemical Protection Coveralls feature sealed seams, an attached hood, and elastic ankles for a secure fit and reliable full-body protection. Constructed from reinforced polyethylene-coated fabric, they provide enhanced durability, excellent coverage performance, and protection against light chemicals
- Light Chemical Resistance: Engineered to provide reliable coverage for light chemicals, it helps protect against many acids, alkalis, and petroleum-based substances
- Anti-Static Fabric: Anti-static treated fabric to reduce the risk of ignition in flammable environments. Suitable for cleanroom, pharmaceutical, and controlled contamination settings
- Multi-Purpose Industrial Use: Suitable for chemical handling, industrial cleaning, oil and gas operations, food processing, and laboratory work
- High Visibility Safety Design: Bright yellow color ensures excellent visibility for added safety in low-light or high-risk environments
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
