Recommended Free Tools
iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Neither an electric heat pump nor a gas furnace is always cheaper or better. A fair comparison uses your local electricity and gas prices, the system’s performance at your winter temperatures, the full installed price, and the home’s insulation and ducts. A heat pump can also provide air conditioning; a gas furnace does not.
How the two systems heat a home
An air-source heat pump moves heat from outdoor air into the home in winter. In summer, it can reverse direction to provide cooling. A gas furnace burns fuel to generate heat; cooling generally requires separate air-conditioning equipment.
A third option is dual fuel: a heat pump handles milder weather, while a gas furnace takes over in colder conditions. Whether that arrangement makes sense depends on equipment, local energy prices, and how the system is controlled.
Compare the costs that matter to your home
Annual energy cost
Estimate how much electricity and gas each proposed system would use in your home, then apply your actual utility rates. Include fixed charges where relevant, and account for the possibility that a heat pump may use electric resistance backup heat during cold weather. For dual-fuel proposals, ask when the system switches to the furnace and how that setting affects expected use.
#1 Best Overall
- All-Season Pool Comfort: Featuring innovative dual-mode temperature control, this heat pump precisely heats water between 41–104°F or cools it within 41–83°F. By maintaining consistent thermal regulation, it extends swimming seasons by up to 6 months while delivering year-round comfort for pool enjoyment.
- Professional Thermal Performance: Featuring a high-output heating module, this 4-season system is designed for above ground pools. The precision thermostat maintains ±2°F temperature accuracy by continuously monitoring ambient conditions, ensuring consistent comfort throughout the year.
- Energy Efficiency Redefined: With a high 5.5 COP, this ultra-efficient heat pump employs a powerful engine to ensure consistent energy savings. In comparison with conventional electric heating, it slashes energy consumption by 70% and provides 40% more savings than natural gas alternatives.
- Quiet Operation & Defrost: With ultra-quiet technology, the operating sound is maintained at 38 dB, which is quieter than a whisper. You can enjoy the comfort brought by the heat pump heating without being affected by any noise.Intelligent auto-defrost system that automatically removes ice buildup without manual intervention.
- Easy to Assemble: This heat pump comes with both 1.25" hose adapters and 1.5" conversion kits for easy installation, completed in under 10 minutes. The panel supports multi-mode smart control, complemented by a 3-year comprehensive warranty and lifetime technical support.
There is no universal bill-savings result. In a 2024 analysis, the U.S. Department of Energy estimated that 13 million U.S. homes heated with natural gas could save by switching to heat pumps. Its examples included average annual savings of $300 in Arizona for homes where a modeled ENERGY STAR variable-speed air-source heat pump was the best choice. A separate Michigan example estimated $1,500 in average annual savings for homes using propane or electricity and a cold-climate model. These are modeled scenarios, not predictions for every home. DOE’s analysis and examples
Field results can differ by location and comparison group. A 2022 Northeast study by Cadmus for DOE found annual energy-cost penalties of $262 for its primary-with-backup natural-gas group and $153 for its whole-home natural-gas group. Those groups included only five and ten sites, respectively, and the findings reflect the study’s sample and energy prices. They are evidence that local rates and system use matter, not a forecast for another household. DOE-hosted 2022 cold-climate study
Rank #2
- Energy-Saving Hybrid Water Heater – Advanced heat pump water heater technology extracts heat from the air to warm water efficiently, cutting electricity use by up to 70% compared to a standard electric water heater.
- High Efficiency Performance – With a 3.75 UEF rating and a 69-gallon First Hour Rating (FHR), this hybrid water heater delivers reliable hot water while significantly lowering energy bills.
- 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater Capacity – Perfect for medium to large households, providing consistent hot water for showers, laundry, and dishes without running out.
- Certified Heat Pump Water Heater – UL Certified, AHRI Certified, and ENERGY STAR rated, ensuring your electric water heater meets the highest standards of safety, efficiency, and performance.
- Long-Lasting Hybrid System – Backed by a 7-year parts warranty and 10-year compressor warranty, this hybrid heat pump water heater is built for durability, savings, and peace of mind.
Full installed project cost
Compare complete proposals, not equipment-only prices. Have contractors itemize any electrical upgrades, duct changes, backup heat, and removal or modification of existing equipment. Ask what is included in commissioning, controls, warranty, and ongoing service. A lower equipment price may not mean a lower project price if additional work is needed.
DOE Federal Energy Management Program lifecycle examples are modeled illustrations, not household quotes. The examples use assumed energy prices based on July 2024 federal-facility averages—11 cents per kWh for electricity and $0.961 per therm for gas—along with assumed equipment lives of 15 years for heat pumps and 21 years for furnaces, among other assumptions. Do not treat their totals as current estimates for your utility bill. DOE furnace purchasing guidance and DOE heat-pump purchasing guidance
Rank #3
- Extend Your Swim Season: The pool heat pump features a dual-mode heating and cooling system that maintains optimal water temperatures year-round. Precision control ensures heating from 47–104℉ and cooling from 47–83℉, allowing you to enjoy extended swimming sessions through autumn’s crisp chill and spring’s cool mornings.
- Rapid Heating & APP Control: Engineered for speed and efficiency, it delivers warmth in hours, perfect for large pools, or chilly climates. Take full control via the app & control panel. Adjust temperatures remotely, track energy use, and program heating schedules to fit your lifestyle.
- Inverter Energy Saving: Intelligent heat pump system featuring full DC variable frequency technology delivers 15.8 COP for maximum heating output. Adaptive frequency conversion algorithm dynamically adjusts power in real-time, achieving 70% energy savings over traditional electric heating and 40% higher efficiency than gas systems.
- Ultra-Quiet & Auto-Defrost: Variable frequency technology reduces operational noise to just 48 dB, paired with an intelligent defrosting system featuring automatically initiated cycles every 40 minutes that complete the process in just 5 minutes, ensuring uninterrupted winter operation with continuous heating performance.
- Easy to Assemble: Our heat pump features 3 versatile connection options designed to integrate with all pools, (1.25" & 1.5" hose adapter, 1.5" adapter conversion kit, 1.5" PVC pipe converter), ensuring hassle-free installation and optimal performance. Enjoy peace of mind with our 3-year warranty. Dive into comfort and reliability.
Compare efficiency ratings on the right basis
Heat pumps and furnaces use different efficiency measures; their numbers are not directly interchangeable. For a heat pump, review the seasonal heating and cooling metrics HSPF2 and SEER2, as well as its heating capacity and efficiency at low outdoor temperatures. For a gas furnace, review AFUE, the seasonal share of fuel energy converted into heat.
Use ENERGY STAR listings and the yellow EnergyGuide label to compare product information, but do not treat a rating alone as an estimate of your bill. To estimate operating cost, combine the proposed equipment’s performance and expected energy use with your local rates. DOE’s purchasing pages explain the metrics and the assumptions in their illustrative comparisons: heat pumps and gas furnaces.
Rank #4
- Strong Heater: Our heat pump pool heater delivers 120000 BTU with a COP of 12.3. It is an energy-efficient heating system that works by extracting heat from the ambient air and transferring it to our pool water, achieving rapid and stable heating. Therefore it is more cost-effective than gas or traditional electric heaters
- Quiet and Versatile: Designed for both freshwater and saltwater, inground pool heater runs at just 47dB, ideal for peaceful swimming in any pool environment with our family
- Inverter Technology, Panel Upgrade: Our upgraded electric pool heater 220v features inverter mode for longer lifespan, lower energy use, and a Intelligent touch control panel with one-button fast heat function
- WiFi Remote: Remotely control your swimming pool heater pumps via app—adjust temperature, schedule run times, or switch modes from anywhere at your convenience
- Quick Setup: Our pool heater for above ground pool includes 1.5-inch connectors and a 118-inch cord, ready to heat pools up to 33000 gallons with minimal setup effort, also designed with water-electric separation for protecting us at home
Check cold-weather capacity and backup heat
Heat pumps are not automatically unsuitable for cold regions, but performance depends on the particular model and the home’s heating load. DOE advises that cold climates need specially designed heat pumps that can operate at lower outdoor temperatures before switching to resistance heating. Ask each contractor for the model’s capacity and efficiency at the outdoor design temperature used for your location—not just its headline rating—and identify what supplies heat if the unit cannot meet demand.
Backup may be electric resistance heat, a gas furnace in a dual-fuel system, or another specified arrangement. Ask when backup operates, how it is controlled, and what that is expected to mean for energy use. In the 2022 Northeast study, the seasonal coefficient of performance averaged 2.34 across 43 sites; that is a measured result from that study, not a guaranteed rating for a new installation. Study details
Best Value
- High BTU Powerful Heating, Energy-Saving & Safe: A new star in pool heating with ETL certification, stylish design, and upgraded next-generation components for reliable performance. The Vidapool pool heat pump delivers up to 75,000 BTU and heats pools up to 21,000 GAL. Using advanced air-source technology to capture heat from the air, it provides high efficiency and can save up to 70% on energy costs compared to natural gas heaters.
- Advanced Technology, Efficient and Worry-Free: Equipped with multiple patented heat exchange technologies and intelligent inverter control, Vidapool pool heat pump automatically switches to low-power operation once the pool water reaches the set temperature.Unlike conventional heaters that shut off completely when target temperature is reached, Vidapool pool heater dynamically adjusts power output for greater energy savings, quieter performance and more consistent comfort.
- Smart Control, Quiet Operation: Smart technology brings convenience to your life. Operating noise is as low as 36dB, running quietly without disturbing daily life.APP remote control is supported, allowing you to adjust water temperature and set schedules via mobile phone, putting your pool temperature fully under your control
- Easy Installation, Year-Round Comfort: Features 3 flexible connection options for perfect compatibility with most pools on the market: 1.25" & 1.5" hose adapter, 1.5" adapter conversion kit, and 1.5" PVC pipe converter. Installation is simple and hassle-free.Easily switch between cooling and heating modes to maintain ideal pool water temperature in any season.
- Full Protection for Your Using Experience: To ensure your comfort and satisfaction during use, we recommend using a pool cover in extreme temperatures to maintain stable water temperature and efficient operation.Our professional after-sales team provides dedicated technical support. If you encounter any issues with your heat pump, please contact us anytime and we will offer professional assistance promptly.
Assess the house before choosing equipment
Insulation, air leakage, and duct condition affect the heating load and how well either system serves the home. DOE recommends weatherizing homes, particularly older ones, before switching from gas to a heat pump. Request a heating-load assessment and properly sized proposals rather than choosing equipment by the size of the existing furnace alone.
Ask the contractor to inspect the ducts and explain any planned repairs or changes. DOE cautions that oversizing, incorrect refrigerant charging, and leaky ducts can reduce efficiency and comfort. Ask how the system will be sized and commissioned, what electrical work is needed, and whether the home’s distribution system is suitable. DOE heat-pump guidance
Compare cooling, controls, and service
If the home needs air conditioning, include that benefit in the comparison: an air-source heat pump can provide heating and cooling, while a gas furnace alone cannot. Compare the heat pump with the furnace plus whatever separate cooling equipment the home would otherwise need.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Ask about maintenance, warranty coverage, and local service availability for the specific equipment. DOE says routine heat-pump maintenance includes filter replacement and refrigerant charging by qualified service personnel. For a heat pump, use a thermostat designed for heat pumps and confirm that it is compatible with the exact system and backup heat. DOE also recommends a heat-pump thermostat that raises temperature gradually to avoid unnecessarily activating electric resistance elements. DOE purchasing guidance
A practical way to compare contractor proposals
- Get a load assessment. Ask for the home’s heating load and a properly sized proposal, including any recommended weatherization or duct work.
- Request complete installed prices. Have each bidder itemize equipment, electrical work, ducts, backup heat, and removal or modification of existing equipment.
- Verify performance at local winter conditions. For a heat pump, request low-temperature capacity and efficiency and a clear backup strategy. For a furnace, note its AFUE and fuel requirements.
- Estimate energy costs with your rates. Ask each bidder to state the expected fuel use and assumptions, including the heat pump’s expected resistance-backup or dual-fuel operation.
- Include cooling and ongoing service. Compare the cooling equipment you need under each option, plus warranty, maintenance, and local service support.
Incentives are location- and date-sensitive. Check current official federal, state, and utility program information for your address rather than assuming a particular tax credit or rebate applies.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
