Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced on October 2, 2026, that California is leading a coalition of 26 states, counties and cities suing the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) over its final rule weakening fuel-economy standards for new passenger cars and light trucks. Filed in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, the case argues that the rule violates federal law. The court has not ruled on those claims in the available sources.

What the lawsuit challenges

The state-and-local coalition’s petition targets NHTSA’s final rule changing corporate average fuel economy standards, commonly called CAFE standards. These standards apply to manufacturers’ fleets of new passenger cars and light trucks. California’s announcement describes the rule as weakening the prior standards, but the available sources do not provide the final rule’s full numerical targets or model-year requirements.

The coalition filed in the First Circuit on October 2, 2026. The Associated Press reported a separate same-day lawsuit by environmental organizations challenging the relaxed rule; that is distinct from the state-and-local coalition’s case. California Department of Justice announcement; Associated Press report.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Why the coalition says the rule is unlawful

The coalition alleges violations of both the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) and the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA). Under the coalition’s reading of EPCA, NHTSA must set CAFE standards at the “maximum feasible” level after considering technological feasibility, economic practicability, the effect of other motor-vehicle standards and the need to conserve energy.

#1 Best Overall
UMEIJA OBD2 Scanner with Upgrade Battery Tester - Diagnostic Tool for Cars That Check Engine Light & Emissions Readiness Read and Clears Vehicle Error Codes for All OBD II Protocol Vehicles Since 1996
  • Multi-Function: This code reader for cars and trucks is like a micro mechanic, which can quickly read and clear engine error codes, live data stream (with graphic display), view freeze frame, check MIL readiness status, read I/M monitoring readiness status and collect vehicle information, display vehicle indicators in detail. You can use it to check fault codes by yourself and display code definitions, understand the health of the vehicle, be fully prepared for going to the auto repair shop for car maintenance.Note: It cannot detect battery life, gearbox faults, output current test, can only detect battery voltage, and can clear fault codes of repaired vehicles.ABS code is not supported.
  • Wide Vehicle Compatibility: Multiple Uses - The OBD2 professional automatic scanner supports all OBDII protocols such as KWP2000, J1850 VPW, ISO9141, J1850 PWM and CAN.Works with most 1996 and newer US cars, 2000 EU and Asian cars, light trucks, SUVs, and newer OBD2 and CAN vehicles both at home and abroad. Please check compatibility with your model before purchasing. This car code reader supports multiple languages ​​such as English, German, French, Spanish, Finnish, Dutch, Russian and Portuguese, making it an ideal choice for international users, deeply loved and highly recommended by customers worldwide.
  • Rugged and Compact Design: The OBD2 scanner is a compact and well-designed car parts. It weighs 12 ounces and measures 8.9 x 6.9 x 1.4 inches. It comes with a 2.5-foot heavy-duty cable with a standard 16-pin OBD connector. The cable is made of a very thick flexible insulation layer and is sturdy and durable. Since OBD2 scanners can easily fall to the ground while working in the car, the structural design of the scanner is very demanding, and this OBD2 scanner can well meet the customer's needs for sturdiness and compactness.
  • Accurate, Fast and Worth Having: The OBD2 code reader adopts an upgraded microprocessor, its powerful performance provides fast and accurate results and displays them on the screen, draws and records real-time vehicle sensor data, helps you understand the condition of the car, quickly diagnose and repair common car problems. 6 buttons for quick operation, plug-and-play design makes it easy to use, you can easily operate it without reading the manual. The OBD2 scanner is not only designed to be lightweight and portable, but also simple, accurate and fast to operate, affordable and more cost-effective, it is a must-have tool for home DIY diagnosis or mechanics to use in auto repair.
  • Battery Tester and Advanced OBDII System Diagnostics: This advanced code reader with battery has a built-in easy-to-use battery tester for monitoring battery life and voltage, helping you quickly assess the battery health of your vehicle, prevent unexpected failures and ensure reliable car performance. At the same time, this engine fault code reader provides advanced diagnostic functions, including testing the O2 sensor and EVAP system to measure oxygen concentration, control the amount of fuel injection, reduce fuel consumption, maintain optimal combustion conditions, improve engine efficiency; reduce exhaust emissions, and better protect the environment.

California’s announcement says NHTSA’s interpretation of that mandate and its analysis fail the statutory test and are arbitrary and capricious. Those are allegations made by parties challenging the rule, not findings by a court. The available sources do not establish a ruling on the merits or any order changing the rule’s status.

California submitted opposition to NHTSA’s proposal in February 2026, before the agency issued the final rule. That earlier submission provides context for the state’s position, but it is not the final rule or the petition filed in October. California’s February 2026 opposition.

Rank #2
Sale
Innova 5210 OBD2 Scanner & Engine Code Reader, Battery Tester, Live Data, Oil Reset, Car Diagnostic Tool for Most Vehicles, Bluetooth Compatible with America's Top Car Repair App
  • OBD2 SCANNER & BATTERY TESTER IN ONE – The INNOVA 5210 OBD2 scanner not only reads and clears check engine light and ABS codes (coverage may vary) but also functions as a car battery tester to check alternator health and prevent unexpected breakdowns.
  • LIVE DATA & REAL-TIME DIAGNOSTICS – Get instant access to OBD2 live data, including RPM, engine temperature, fuel trims, and oxygen sensor readings. The drive cycle readiness feature helps pass smog tests and emissions inspections with ease.
  • ENGINE CODE READER – This automotive diagnostic tool works with most US, Asian, and European vehicles from 1996 and newer, including Toyota, Ford, Honda, Chevrolet, Nissan, Dodge, and more. Read and erase ABS (coverage may vary) and engine trouble codes with pinpoint accuracy. Please use Innova's Coverage Checker to verify coverage.
  • OIL RESET & SMOG CHECK READINESS – The built-in oil light reset feature allows DIYers and mechanics to properly reset maintenance lights after an oil change. Check I/M readiness status to ensure your car is ready for an emissions test.
  • NO SUBSCRIPTIONS – VERIFIED FIXES WITH FREE APP – Unlike other OBD2 code readers, the INNOVA 5210 provides verified fixes based on real-world repairs from ASE-certified mechanics. Trusted by 4M users, the RepairSolutions2 app on iPhone & Android gives you step-by-step repair guidance, suggested parts, and cost estimates—no extra fees or hidden subscriptions!

What the competing savings estimates mean

The parties describe consumer costs differently. Their figures refer to different effects and time frames, and the underlying analyses are not included in the available sources. Neither figure is a measured outcome, and the estimates cannot be directly compared or subtracted to determine which is correct.

What’s actually slowing this PC down?

Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
Who made the claim Figure and measure What the figure represents
California Attorney General’s office Nearly $220 billion in fuel savings California’s estimate of fuel savings drivers would have received under the previous standards but will forgo under the rule. It is a counterfactual projection, not a realized loss. California Department of Justice announcement.
U.S. Department of Justice, speaking for the administration $109 billion over five years The administration’s estimate of savings from its CAFE reset. It is a projection, not an observed result. U.S. Department of Justice statement.
U.S. Department of Justice, speaking for the administration $1,000 on the average new vehicle The administration’s estimate of savings on the average new vehicle. It is not a measured reduction in vehicle prices. U.S. Department of Justice statement.

The estimates describe different claimed effects: California focuses on fuel savings forgone against the prior standards, while the administration cites savings associated with its reset, including an average-vehicle figure. The sources do not supply enough underlying assumptions to independently assess or rank the projections.

Rank #3
ANCEL AD410 PRO OBD2 Scanner and Battery Tester, 2-in-1 Car Diagnostic Tool, Check Engine Light, EVAP Test, Live Data, 12V Battery Analyzer with Cranking & Charging System Test for Car Motorcycle
  • 【2-IN-1 Engine Diagnostic & Battery Tester】: Upgraded from ANCEL’s best-selling AD310/AD410 series, the AD410 PRO obd2 scanner not only offers deeper, more accurate engine fault diagnosis but also covers battery health assessment, starter motor testing, and charging system evaluation. Skip buying separate tools—save money and space while eliminating the hassle of switching between different diagnostic scan tool
  • 【Silence the Check Engine Light】: Panicked when the check engine light suddenly pops on? This car code reader decodes 42,000+ SAE DTCs in seconds (e.g. “P0300 – Multiple Cylinder Misfire”)—no confusing jargon. Read codes, understand the issue, then clear the light after fixing—so you avoid guesswork and unnecessary shop fees. NOTE: It DOESN'T support ABS, SRS, or Transmission systems
  • 【Comprehensive Battery System Test】: Stop guessing why your car struggles to start—is it the battery, starter, or alternator? AD410 PRO goes beyond a voltage-only check by performing battery health, cranking, and charging system tests to pinpoint where the issue is coming from. Prevent unnecessary replacements and costly repeat repairs—know what's wrong and fix it right, without the guesswork
  • 【Avoid a Smog Re-Test】: No more panic before emissions tests! The dedicated I/M Readiness mode of this professional obd2 scanner diagnostic tool instantly shows your vehicle’s compliance status (green = ready, yellow = incomplete). It covers core monitoring items (misfire, fuel system, catalyst, etc.) — fix potential issues in advance so you know you’re ready before you go, avoiding wasted time and extra inspection fees
  • 【Live Data for Instant Vehicle Insights】: Don’t just read codes—see what your engine is doing in real time with this car scanner. Track 50+ key live readings with visual dashboards and waveform graphs to spot overheating, sensor issues, or fuel/air issues early. Freeze frame replays the exact moment a fault happened (speed/load/temp), so you know what triggered the check engine light—no more guessing

Other effects disputed by California

California says the rule ends the CAFE credit-trading program in 2028 and alleges that the change will significantly harm electric-vehicle industries employing Californians. Both the rule description and the forecasted industry effect are the state’s claims in its announcement; the available sources do not include the final rule text or an independent assessment of the projected harm.

The state also alleges that NHTSA’s analysis is deficient in its treatment of affordability, vehicle sales, fleet turnover, fuel savings and vehicle safety, and that the agency excludes future climate-damage costs. These points are part of the coalition’s challenge, not adjudicated conclusions. California Department of Justice announcement.

Rank #4
Sale
FOXWELL NT301 Plus 2-in-1 OBD2 Scanner & 12V Car Battery Tester
  • Same with NT301. Extra Battery Test — One Tool solve two common issues for car. Upgraded from the NT301, the NT301 Plus code reader reads and clears engine codes just as fast as the classic you trust. But now, it also checks your 12V battery health. Think of the extra cost as cheap insurance against the high tow truck bill. As one user put it: "It paid for itself the first time I plugged it in." With a 36% larger 2.8” color display (vs. 2.4”), it delivers clearer results every time. Ideal for DIYers, car owners, home mechanics, used car inspection and anyone who wants to diagnose car issues with confidence before making a costly shop visit
  • Check Engine Light on? — Plug it in and the 2.8" color screen shows you the code and exactly what it means—no mechanic-speak, no decoding. You'll know what you're dealing with before you enter into a repair shop with this code reader for cars and trucks. Access live data like RPM, coolant temp, and fuel trim to pinpoint the problem. Saved money from taking it to the shop and spending over hundreds to figure out the reason. Pro Tip: You should fix the car issue before clearing the codes
  • Check Battery Health You Didn't Know You Needed — Don’t wait until your car won’t start. Taking few mintues to check battery health (SOH, SOC, cranking/starting power & charging system). Works with 12V lead-acid batteries: Flooded, AGM (flat/spiral), EFB, and GEL. This car battery tester will test your battery before daily commuting, road trips, after a jump-start, new battery keeps dying or vehicle sitting for weeks. Know whether to recharge, replace, or keep using your battery to avoid unnecessary battery replacement. Knowledge is power—and in this case, it's also a working car. Tips: Connect the battery cable firmly to the OBDII diagnostic cable to start battery check
  • See What Your Engine IS Doing — This car diagnostics scanner monitors real-time engine parameters to catch intermittent issues: RPM, sensor outputs, fuel trim, and more. The obd scanner supports data recording, playback, and PC printing of diagnostic reports—ideal for professional repairs faster and easier
  • Know Your S-m-o-g Status & Find EVAP Leaks — Whether you're buying used, chasing a stubborn check engine light, or just want to be sure you'll pass your next s-m-o-g check—this car scanner diagnostic tool scan gives you answers in minutes. Run the I/M readiness test, check for stored codes the seller didn't mention, and test battery health. Some of you used it on a car was about to buy, saw a stored code, and passed. That kind of information pays for itself. Also works for EVAP leak detection—loose gas cap or cracked hose, you'll know before the shop tells you
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

What is known about the case’s status

The available sources establish that the coalition filed its challenge in the First Circuit on October 2, 2026. They do not establish later court action, provide a current docket entry or show that the court has granted relief. Readers should distinguish the filing itself from any eventual ruling: the petition presents the coalition’s case, while the court determines whether the challenged rule is lawful.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

California’s earlier disputes over federal clean-car standards and state authority are background, not this lawsuit. California Attorney General’s background page.

Best Value
2-in-1 OBD2 Scanner with Battery Tester: 1S Read & Clear Check Engine Codes + Test Battery in 3 Mins - DIY Car Diagnostic Tool with Cold Cranking Amps for Pre-Trip Safety on 1996+ Vehicles
  • 2-in-1 OBD2 Scanner & Battery Tester – Diagnosis in Under 3 Minutes – Read & clear check engine codes in 1 second, then run a full 12V/24V battery health test in minutes—all in one device. Measures 6 key battery indicators: CCA, SOC, SOH, internal resistance, cranking test & charging system status. Whether it's an engine fault or a dying battery, pinpoint the root cause fast—no mechanic, no guesswork, no wasted repair costs.
  • 3 Real-World Use Cases, 1 Tool – Run a pre-road trip safety scan to catch hidden faults before you hit the highway. Test cold-cranking performance before winter to avoid surprise no-starts in freezing temps. Inspect a used car on the spot before buying—check battery health and engine codes in minutes. Large backlit screen + icon-guided results mean zero learning curve, even for first-time users.
  • See Your Car's Health Clearly – No Mechanic Jargon – Features a 2.8" HD color screen with built-in DTC code definitions so you understand exactly what's wrong—no Googling required. View live data stream with curve graphs to spot intermittent issues in real time. Supports 13 languages for global users. Far beyond basic code readers that only show fault codes with no explanation—this scan tool shows you the full picture, instantly.
  • Full-System Car Diagnostic Tool – Engine, Transmission & More – Goes beyond basic OBD2 scanners to scan all major vehicle systems, including transmission faults, and emissions readiness. Read and clear codes across all 10 OBD2 protocols, with I/M readiness status to check if your car will pass emissions testing. Compatible with all 1996+ OBD2 vehicles—cars, trucks, SUVs, and EU models 2003+. Thousands of verified buyers rely on this tool to handle repairs themselves and cut dealership visits for good.
  • Perfect Gift for Any Driver – Worry-Free for 18 Months – Whether it's for a new driver, a road-trip enthusiast, or a DIY car owner, this scanner arrives in premium gift packaging—ready to give, no setup needed. Backed by an 18-month warranty and responsive customer support, so every purchase is risk-free. A gift they'll actually use: one tool that handles both engine diagnostics and battery health, saving hundreds in shop visits for years to come.

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.