iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
“Stalin’s dream” was Richard Stallman’s deliberately provocative description of cell phones—not a neutral technical label. In a 2011 Network World article, readers debated whether phones’ tracking and potential eavesdropping capabilities justified his warning, whether his language overstated the danger, and how privacy concerns compare with phones’ everyday and political uses. The technical distinction that matters: cellular networks can estimate a powered-on, registered phone’s location without GPS, while GPS and apps create separate location pathways.
What Stallman meant by “Stalin’s dream”
Network World’s Jon Brodkin quoted Richard Stallman, founder of the free-software movement and creator of GNU, saying: “I don’t have a cell phone. I won’t carry a cell phone,” and, “It’s Stalin’s dream. Cell phones are tools of Big Brother. I’m not going to carry a tracking device that records where I go all the time, and I’m not going to carry a surveillance device that can be turned on to eavesdrop.” Network World’s March 16, 2011 article treated the remarks as the start of a debate, not as a settled technical verdict.
The language makes a broad political judgment about surveillance and power. The underlying concerns are more specific: a phone can reveal location through network connections or other services, and its microphone and software raise separate questions about access and control. The 2011 article collected reader opinions about those risks; its comment roundup does not independently prove every claim commenters made about particular agencies or capabilities.
How a phone’s location can be observed
“Location tracking” can refer to several mechanisms. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), in its Surveillance Self-Defense guide last reviewed November 5, 2024, describes tracking through cellular signals and towers, cell-site simulators, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, and information leaked by apps or web browsing. The methods differ, and none should be confused with the claim that GPS satellites receive a phone’s location.
#1 Best Overall
- YOUR CONTENT, SUPER SMOOTH: The ultra-clear 6.7" FHD+ Super AMOLED display of Galaxy A17 5G helps bring your content to life, whether you're scrolling through recipes or video chatting with loved ones.¹
- LIVE FAST. CHARGE FASTER: Focus more on the moment and less on your battery percentage with Galaxy A17 5G. Super Fast Charging powers up your battery so you can get back to life sooner.²
- MEMORIES MADE PICTURE PERFECT: Capture every angle in stunning clarity, from wide family photos to close-ups of friends, with the triple-lens camera on Galaxy A17 5G.
- NEED MORE STORAGE? WE HAVE YOU COVERED: With an improved 2TB of expandable storage, Galaxy A17 5G makes it easy to keep cherished photos, videos and important files readily accessible whenever you need them.³
- BUILT TO LAST: With an improved IP54 rating, Galaxy A17 5G is even more durable than before.⁴ It’s built to resist splashes and dust and comes with a stronger yet slimmer Gorilla Glass Victus front and Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer back.
Cellular networks
A carrier can estimate where a phone is when it is powered on and registered with the network, based on its interactions with cellular infrastructure. How precise that estimate can be depends on factors such as network technology and tower density. Turning off GPS does not, by itself, prevent this carrier-side observation. EFF says there is little a person can do to prevent this type of tracking while carrying a powered-on phone registered on the network. EFF explains the pathways and limitations in its mobile-phone guide.
GPS, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and apps
GPS is a receiver-based method: the handset uses satellite signals to determine its position. The phone may then share that position through an app or network connection. Wi-Fi and Bluetooth can also contribute to location tracking, and apps or web browsing can expose location-related information. These pathways are distinct from a carrier’s ability to estimate a registered phone’s location from cellular network activity.
Rank #2
- Unlocked: Compatible with all major U.S. carriers, including Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile and other major carriers.
- Super-bright 6.7" display + Bass Boost: Take your entertainment to the next level with a fast-refreshing 120Hz display* and stereo sound with more powerful bass****.
- 50MP** Quad Pixel camera system: Capture sharper photos day or night with 4x the light sensitivity—and share beautiful selfies with a 16MP front camera.
- Superfast 5G performance*****: Unleash your entertainment at 5G speed with the MediaTek Dimensity 6300 chipset and up to 12GB of RAM with RAM Boost.******
- Long-lasting battery + TurboPower charging***: Work and play all day with a 5000mAh battery, then get hours of power in just minutes.
What readers disagreed about
Network World reported more than 1,000 comments on the debate, including about 700 on Slashdot. Those are the article’s contemporary discussion totals, not a measure of current opinion. The responses it summarized fall into several arguments:
The warning is credible
Some readers thought tracking capabilities and past surveillance controversies warranted concern. Those commenters’ views show why the warning resonated, but the roundup should not be treated as independent confirmation of every historical assertion they made.
Rank #3
- Please note, this device does not support E-SIM; This 4G model is compatible with all GSM networks worldwide outside of the U.S. In the US, ONLY compatible with T-Mobile and their MVNO's (Metro and Standup). It will NOT work with Verizon, Spectrum, AT&T, Total Wireless, other CDMA carriers, it is also not compatible with their MVNO (Visible, Xfinity Mobile, US Mobile, Cricket Wireless, etc).
- Compatibility with certain third-party devices and accessibility accessories, including some hearing aids, may vary depending on manufacturer support, Bluetooth protocols, software compatibility, and regional firmware limitations. For additional hearing aid compatibility information, please refer to Samsung’s official support documentation.
- 4G LTE Bands: B1/B3/B5/B7/B8/B20/B28/B38/B40/B41
- Display: Super AMOLED, 90Hz, 800 nits (HBM) | 6.7 inches, 110.2 cm2 (~86.0% screen-to-body ratio) | 1080 x 2340 pixels, 19.5:9 ratio (~385 ppi density)
- Camera: 50 MP, f/1.8, (wide), 1/2.76", 0.64µm, AF | 50 MP, f/1.8, (wide), 1/2.76", 0.64µm, AF | 2 MP, f/2.4, (macro)
The warning is overstated
Other readers objected to Stallman’s rhetoric, questioned whether authorities would target ordinary people, or noted that a person can leave a phone behind. These points address different questions: whether a technical capability exists, whether a particular person is likely to be targeted, and whether carrying a phone is worth the trade-off. Low perceived targeting risk does not erase a capability; a capability alone does not establish that everyone is under active, individualized surveillance.
Free software helps with one part of the problem
Stallman’s argument emphasizes control over phone software. GNU’s position is that mobile phones are tracking devices and that proprietary software can raise additional concerns; that is the Free Software Foundation’s advocacy position. But reader objections in 2011 pointed out that free software cannot make a phone invisible to the cellular network. EFF’s distinction clarifies the issue: software control and carrier visibility are separate layers. A user’s control over apps or operating-system code does not eliminate the location information inherent in a powered-on phone’s network registration.
Rank #4
- TYPE IT IN. TRANSFORM IT FAST: Enhance any shot in seconds on your smartphone by using Photo Assist¹ with Galaxy AI.² Add objects, restore details, or apply new styles by simply typing or tapping
- MAKE IT. EDIT IT. SHARE IT: Turn everyday moments into something personal with creative tools built right into your mobile whether it’s a special contact photo, custom wallpaper, an invitation or more³
- FAST. POWERFUL. AI-READY: Power through your day with AI-accelerated performance from our fastest, smoothest and most powerful Galaxy processor yet, built to keep up with everything you do
- IMMENSELY IMMERSIVE: No matter where you are or what you’re watching, your favorite videos and more come to life with the vibrant display on Galaxy S26
- FIT EVERYONE IN THE SHOT: Group selfies are easier on your Samsung phone with a wider front camera⁴ that captures more of the scene, so no one gets left out of the moment
Phones can be useful and intrusive at once
Readers also argued that phones can enable rapid communication and political organizing, including in freedom movements, even as they create privacy risks. Network World records that as a trade-off raised in the discussion, not as a quantified or universal finding that phones either cause political change or inevitably undermine it.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
What can an individual do—and what is beyond individual settings?
Practical steps depend on which tracking route concerns you. App permissions and location services may affect what apps receive, but switching off GPS is not a way to stop carrier-side location estimation when the phone remains powered on and registered. Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, browsing and app disclosures are additional pathways to consider. EFF’s guide describes these categories; it also makes clear that avoiding carrier tracking while carrying a connected phone is not simply a matter of changing a location setting.
Best Value
- This pre-owned product is not Apple certified, but has been professionally inspected, tested and cleaned by Amazon-qualified suppliers.
- There will be no visible cosmetic imperfections when held at an arm’s length.
- This product is eligible for a replacement or refund within 90 days of receipt if you are not satisfied.
- Product may come in generic Box.
That limitation connects Stallman’s personal choice to a broader policy question. A person can decide not to carry a phone, or to limit how and when it is used, but network practices and legal safeguards are not controlled by individual software choices. The 2011 debate captured both sides of that tension: concern about infrastructure-level visibility and the practical value of being reachable.
So, are cell phones “Stalin’s dream”?
It is best understood as Stallman’s political metaphor, not a literal or technically precise description of every phone or every user’s experience. The surveillance concern has a concrete basis: carriers can estimate the location of phones registered on their networks, and apps and other wireless systems add distinct ways location information may be exposed. But the metaphor alone cannot establish how often a person is targeted, what a particular device permits, or whether the benefits of carrying a phone outweigh the risks for that individual.
The 2011 reader question—“But is such behavior necessary for those of us who don’t gain attention from a large and powerful organization with sophisticated surveillance technology?”—remains a question about risk tolerance, not a technical rebuttal. One Network World commenter, Frukt, joked: “Let them track me. Must be the most boring job on Earth.” That quip illustrates one response to the perceived likelihood of scrutiny; it is not evidence that tracking is harmless or that the same risk applies to everyone.
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallCrashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minuteQuick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
