Soulslike vs Action RPG: What’s the Difference and Which Should You Play?

iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Short answer: a Soulslike is usually an action RPG built around deliberate, high-consequence combat, dangerous exploration, checkpoints, death, and learning through repeated attempts. Action RPG is the broader category: it combines real-time combat with role-playing progression, so it also includes faster, more forgiving games with selectable difficulty, heavier loot systems, or lighter penalties for failure.

Elden Ring sits between those descriptions. It keeps the Soulslike combat and discovery loop, but adds an open world, multiple routes, stealth, mounted travel, summons, online allies, and enough build flexibility to postpone or avoid many fights. Choose a traditional Soulslike when you want concentrated mastery and meaningful risk; choose a broader action RPG when you want more safety nets, speed, explicit quests, or a stronger gear-driven power curve.

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		ELDEN RING - Shadow of the Erdtree - Xbox [Digital Code]	$39.99	Buy on Amazon
2		Elden Ring, 1 PS5-Blu-ray Disc	$74.27	Buy on Amazon
3		Elden Ring: Official Art Book Volume III: Shadow of the Erdtree	$33.94	Buy on Amazon

What is an action RPG?

An action RPG combines the moment-to-moment control of an action game with the long-term growth systems of a role-playing game. Combat happens in real time rather than through a command menu, while your character becomes more capable through some combination of levels, attributes, weapons, armor, skills, abilities, loot, or build choices.

The label covers a very wide range of designs. One action RPG may emphasize fast attacks, large enemy groups, and spectacular abilities. Another may revolve around careful positioning and limited resources. Some use selectable difficulty and frequent checkpoints; others expect you to repeat encounters until you understand them. Story can be delivered through cinematic quests, party dialogue, environmental clues, or a mixture of all three.

#1 Best Overall

ELDEN RING - Shadow of the Erdtree - Xbox [Digital Code]

• Playable on 21st June 2024.
• Pre-order now and get the following bonus content for the expansion: ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree Bonus Gesture
• Winner of hundreds of accolades including The Game Awards Game of the Year and Golden Joystick Awards Ultimate Game of the Year, ELDEN RING is the acclaimed action RPG epic set in a vast, dark fantasy world. Players embark on an epic quest with the freedom to explore and adventure at their own pace.
• The Shadow of the Erdtree expansion features an all-new story set in the Land of Shadow imbued with mystery, perilous dungeons, and new enemies, weapons and equipment.
• Discover uncharted territories, face formidable adversaries, and revel in the satisfying triumph of victory. Dive into the riveting interplay of characters, where drama and intrigue intertwine, that create an immersive experience to savor and enjoy.

$39.99

Buy on Amazon

That breadth is why “action RPG” does not tell you exactly how a game feels to play. It identifies the combination of real-time action and role-playing progression, but it does not specify the pace of combat, the cost of dying, the structure of exploration, or how much execution matters compared with character statistics and equipment.

What is a Soulslike?

“Soulslike” is a comparative design label, not an official genre with a fixed checklist. It describes games that meaningfully adopt the design language popularized by FromSoftware’s Souls games. The most useful test is the complete play loop rather than any single feature:

1. Enter a dangerous area. Enemies, traps, terrain, and routes create meaningful risk before the next safe point.
2. Read behavior and commit to actions. Attacks, blocks, dodges, parries, healing, and movement have timing and recovery costs.
3. Reach a checkpoint or shortcut. Safe points break up the route and often reveal how the level is constructed.
4. Risk progress when you die. Defeat may leave resources or progress in a recoverable location, making the next attempt a choice between caution and further advancement.
5. Learn through repetition. Knowledge of enemy patterns, spacing, routes, and your own build gradually changes an apparently impossible encounter into a manageable one.

Individual games can omit or soften parts of this loop. A title may provide generous checkpoints, alternative routes, summons, or powerful build options and still feel like a Soulslike if failure, exploration, and combat learning remain tightly connected. Conversely, a game can be very hard without using this structure.

Soulslike vs action RPG: the practical differences

The categories overlap: most Soulslikes are action RPGs, but most action RPGs are not Soulslikes. Compare them by the systems that shape your decisions minute by minute.

These are tendencies, not legal definitions. Modern games mix systems, so use the label as a prediction tool: ask whether the title makes you learn a dangerous space and its enemies through costly, repeatable attempts. That answer is more informative than a store category.

Why combat feels different in a Soulslike

Stamina turns every action into a decision

In a typical Soulslike, attacking, blocking, dodging, sprinting, and sometimes other defensive actions draw from a stamina resource. The official Elden Ring starter guide puts the consequence plainly: “When it reaches zero, you won’t be able to perform any further actions that consume stamina.” Stamina automatically regenerates and is not consumed outside combat. The result is a rhythm of acting, creating space, and waiting for recovery rather than attacking continuously.

That system does not make every fight slow. It makes timing and commitment visible. A short attack string may be safe against one enemy but leave you unable to dodge a delayed strike from another. A shield can absorb a hit, yet holding it up may limit stamina recovery or movement. A player who watches the resource bar and the opponent’s animation is making a different kind of decision from a player who can cancel every move into another attack.

Enemy reading replaces guesswork with information

Soulslike combat rewards observing attack timing, range, recovery windows, and tells. You learn whether an enemy follows a swing with a second hit, how far a lunge travels, when a boss can be safely struck, and which animation signals an area attack. Repeated attempts are not merely retries; they reveal information that changes your next plan.

This is why a higher level or better weapon does not automatically solve every encounter. Statistics can widen your margin for error, but the decisive improvement often comes from recognizing when to wait, where to stand, and which opening is real rather than bait.

Commitment creates tension

Many Soulslike actions have recovery animations. Once an attack, heal, or heavy movement begins, you may not be able to cancel it immediately. The game therefore asks you to commit before you know with certainty what the enemy will do. Good play comes from choosing actions whose timing and spacing you understand, not from reacting after every mistake has already started.

Broader action RPGs can use commitment too, but they may offset it with faster cancels, crowd-control skills, companions, abundant healing, or a difficulty setting that reduces incoming damage. Those tools change the source of challenge without making the combat better or worse; they simply ask for a different kind of attention.

Checkpoints, shortcuts, and the meaning of death

Checkpoints do more than save your game. In a Soulslike, their placement determines how much of a route you must understand before a difficult fight. A checkpoint near a boss lets you study the boss without replaying a long approach. A distant checkpoint makes the path itself part of the test, encouraging you to identify a shortcut, decide which enemies can be bypassed, and conserve healing for the final room.

Death gives the route and your resources a cost. When a game lets you recover what was left behind, the next attempt presents a risk calculation: retrieve the loss, spend it safely, or continue deeper and risk losing it again. Even when a particular title changes the exact penalty, the design purpose is similar. Defeat tells you where your plan failed and asks you to apply that information under pressure.

Hidetaka Miyazaki has described the goal this way: “We understand that Souls-like games are regularly associated with impossible levels of difficulty with high barriers to entry. But we try to design the games to make the cycle of repeatedly trying to overcome these challenges enjoyable in itself.” The important distinction is that repetition is intended to produce knowledge, not simply consume time.

Is every hard action RPG a Soulslike?

No. Difficulty alone is not the definition. A difficult action game with separate stages, generous resets, a combo-focused system, or challenge based mainly on enemy health may feel nothing like a Soulslike. Likewise, an action RPG can become demanding because its hardest mode increases damage or reduces healing without using dangerous interconnected routes, recovery risks, or deliberate stamina-based combat.

Ask these questions instead:

• Do attacks, dodges, blocks, and heals have meaningful timing and recovery?
• Does the game teach you enemy behavior through observation and repeated attempts?
• Are checkpoints, shortcuts, and exploration designed around the possibility of failure?
• Does death affect your route, resources, or momentum rather than merely restarting a self-contained stage?
• Can better execution compensate for an imperfect build, while poor timing can still defeat a highly leveled character?

If most answers are yes, “Soulslike” is a useful expectation. If the game is simply punishing while using a different combat and checkpoint structure, “hard action RPG” is more accurate.

Rank #3

Sale

Elden Ring: Official Art Book Volume III: Shadow of the Erdtree

$33.94

Buy on Amazon

Where Elden Ring fits

Elden Ring is an action RPG with strong Soulslike lineage. Its official description calls it a “refined action-RPG” and highlights a large connected world, character creation, weapons, magic, stealth, summons, online allies, and combat built around reading an enemy and timing a dodge or parry.

Its open-world structure changes how you respond to difficulty. You can choose another route, explore for equipment or abilities, use mounted travel with Torrent, approach some situations through stealth, exploit the environment, or call on other tools and allies. Bandai Namco’s beginner guidance explicitly encourages avoiding enemies that are too strong, choosing your own route, and returning later rather than treating every obstacle as a mandatory test at that moment.

That flexibility does not remove the Soulslike fundamentals. Boss attacks still demand pattern recognition, stamina still limits consecutive actions, and an unsafe heal can still be punished. It does mean that a failed attempt often produces more options than “try the same room again”: change your weapon, alter your build, summon help, find a different approach, or leave and come back stronger.

Why Elden Ring works as a bridge

Elden Ring is a strong first choice when you want to sample Soulslike combat but are concerned about being trapped by one difficult encounter. Its open world supplies detours, and its systems support experimentation with weapons, magical abilities, and skills. Mounted travel reduces the friction of crossing large spaces; stealth can let you thin or bypass threats; summons and online allies can share pressure during difficult fights.

The trade-off is complexity. More weapons, attributes, optional areas, and possible routes can make it harder to know what to prioritize. The game gives you freedom rather than a single ideal sequence, so players who prefer a tightly authored route may find the open world less immediately legible than a compact, linear Soulslike.

Which should you play?

Choose a Soulslike first if you want earned mastery

• You enjoy studying patterns and improving through repetition.
• You prefer combat in which each swing, dodge, heal, or parry has a cost.
• You like discovering shortcuts, hidden routes, and story clues without being told exactly where to look.
• You want execution and knowledge to matter as much as character level.
• You find a successful rematch satisfying even when the first attempt ended quickly.

For the pure foundational formula, Dark Souls: Remastered is a natural starting point. Bandai Namco presents the Dark Souls trilogy as foundational to this design philosophy, summarized by the line, “Every death is a lesson. Every lesson moves you forward.” Its tighter world structure makes the relationship between routes, shortcuts, checkpoints, and combat easier to see than in a huge open world.

Choose a broader action RPG first if you want flexibility

• You want faster or more forgiving combat, or a selectable difficulty level.
• You prefer explicit quests, party systems, or a stronger loot-and-leveling power curve.
• You dislike repeating a route after a defeat.
• You want the story and progression to remain predictable while you experiment with builds.
• You would rather solve a difficult encounter by changing equipment or abilities than by memorizing every attack.

This choice is not an admission that you cannot handle a Soulslike. It reflects what you want the game to reward. A broader action RPG may reward planning a build, coordinating a party, rotating abilities, or using gear upgrades; a Soulslike places more weight on timing, spacing, and the knowledge gained from failure.

Choose Elden Ring when you want both sides

Pick Elden Ring if you want demanding combat but also value exploration freedom, multiple build paths, stealth, summons, mounted travel, online cooperation, and the option to postpone encounters. It preserves the high-consequence identity while giving beginners more ways to create a favorable situation. You can still pursue a highly disciplined, no-assistance challenge, but the game does not require that approach for every obstacle.

A practical first-session plan for a Soulslike

The following approach applies the genre’s systems without assuming a particular control scheme or build.

1. Learn one defensive option. Practice a dodge, block, or parry against a low-risk enemy until you can recognize the timing. Do not add several techniques at once.
2. Watch stamina before watching damage numbers. Leave enough resource for an escape. If your bar is nearly empty, stop attacking and create distance while it regenerates.
3. Test one attack at a time. Notice its range, recovery, and how many follow-up hits are safe. A shorter sequence that leaves you mobile is often more useful than a larger combo you cannot finish safely.
4. Map the route to the next checkpoint. Identify enemies that can be bypassed, a shortcut that can be opened, and a safe location for healing or regrouping.
5. Treat the first boss attempt as reconnaissance. Observe phases, delays, reach, and punish windows. Surviving longer is not the only measure of progress; learning one reliable tell is progress too.
6. Change one variable after a defeat. Try a different distance, timing, weapon, summon, route, or defensive response. Changing everything at once makes it difficult to know what solved the problem.

Common misconceptions and how to avoid them

“Soulslike means no help is allowed”

Assistance is part of the design space. Summons, online allies, flexible builds, stealth, environmental advantages, and alternative routes can all soften a particular obstacle. Using them changes the challenge you are choosing; it does not invalidate the game or the genre.

“Leveling makes skill irrelevant”

Progression can increase health, damage, equipment options, or defensive margin, but it cannot guarantee that you will recognize a delayed attack or stop healing in an unsafe window. A stronger character may give you more chances to learn, which is useful, but execution remains a central part of the loop.

“A game needs a punishment-free checkpoint system to be fun”

Players differ in how much route repetition they enjoy. The point of a Soulslike checkpoint is not to waste time; it is to make the space between safety and danger meaningful. If repeated travel feels like friction rather than learning, a broader action RPG with more frequent resets may be a better fit.

“Genre labels are objective store categories”

They are not. Publishers, critics, and players use “Soulslike” differently, and modern games borrow individual mechanics without adopting the whole loop. Evaluate the actual combat, failure, exploration, and progression systems before relying on the label.

Decision guide

The bottom line

Action RPG is the umbrella; Soulslike is a particular way of organizing challenge, combat, exploration, checkpoints, failure, and learning within or alongside that umbrella. Difficulty by itself does not define the style. The defining question is whether the game expects you to read dangerous situations, commit to costly actions, recover from defeat, and improve through repeated attempts.

Start with a focused Soulslike if that learning loop sounds appealing. Start with a broader action RPG if you want speed, safety nets, explicit progression, or selectable difficulty. For many newcomers, Elden Ring is the best bridge because it retains the demanding combat identity while letting you explore elsewhere, experiment with builds, use stealth or summons, travel on Torrent, and return to a problem when you are ready.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

ELDEN RING - Shadow of the Erdtree - Xbox [Digital Code]

Playable on 21st June 2024.

$39.99

Bestseller No. 2

Elden Ring, 1 PS5-Blu-ray Disc

$74.27

SaleBestseller No. 3

Elden Ring: Official Art Book Volume III: Shadow of the Erdtree

$33.94

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.