Recommended Free Tools
iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
There is no official NBA “what-if” ranking, and no statistic can measure the career a player might have had without injury or other interruption. The strongest cases combine a demonstrated high point with a major change in a player’s trajectory. On the evidence available for this article, Bill Walton, Derrick Rose, Brandon Roy, Grant Hill and Greg Oden make a defensible ranked five—not a responsibly verified top ten.
How this ranking weighs a what-if career
The order is editorial, not an NBA finding. It weighs four questions: how much elite NBA ability the player had already shown; how abruptly and when the career changed; how much of the expected prime was lost; and how uncertain the imagined alternative remains. Those questions do not produce a precise score, and they should not be mistaken for one.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
NBA 75: The Definitive History | $20.13 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Courtside: Four decades of unforgettable NBA plays, legends, and championship moments from the... | $28.98 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
NBA Legends | $29.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
A History of Basketball in Fifteen Sneakers | $19.38 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
The Book of Basketball: The NBA According to The Sports Guy | $12.59 | Buy on Amazon |
The list focuses on careers that began in the NBA. Len Bias is a different kind of what-if: he died before playing an NBA game. That makes any imagined NBA impact impossible to compare directly with an established player’s injury-interrupted career. Yao Ming and Penny Hardaway are also frequently raised in discussions of the subject, but the records cited here do not support placing them fairly alongside the five ranked players.
1. Bill Walton: an MVP career repeatedly limited by injury
Walton ranks first because the what-if begins with extraordinary achievement, not merely promise. NBA.com’s retrospective records that he won the 1977–78 MVP after averaging 18.9 points, 13.2 rebounds, 5.0 assists and 2.52 blocks per game in 58 appearances. The Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame also recognizes his MVP and All-NBA First Team honors, a Boston championship, and chronic foot and knee injuries. NBA.com’s Walton retrospective; Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame profile.
#1 Best Overall
NBA.com says Walton appeared in 44 percent of regular-season contests over his NBA years. That figure makes the lost availability vivid, but it does not tell us what his career totals or team results would have been if he had stayed healthy. He already achieved MVP-level success and championships; the question is what additional sustained excellence might have been possible.
NBA.com also reproduces a judgment from Walton’s Portland coach, Dr. Jack Ramsay, attributed to Sport magazine: “Bill Russell was a great shotblocker. Wilt Chamberlain was a great offensive player. But Walton can do it all.” It is a coach’s assessment quoted by a secondary source, not a measurable comparison.
Rank #2
2. Derrick Rose: a clear turning point after an MVP peak
Rose’s case is unusually easy to locate in time: NBA.com’s retrospective identifies his devastating knee injury during the 2012 first-round series against Philadelphia as the turning point, and describes him as the youngest MVP in league history. The contrast between a documented MVP peak and the career that followed gives the what-if its force. NBA.com’s Derrick Rose retrospective.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
That before-and-after does not prove that Rose would have won more awards, championships or seasons at the same level without the injury. Those outcomes are unknowable. The grounded claim is narrower: the injury interrupted the path of a player who had already reached the league’s highest individual honor.
Rank #3
3. Brandon Roy: a short NBA career with strong per-game production
Roy’s NBA.com player page lists six years of NBA experience and career averages of 18.8 points, 4.3 rebounds and 4.7 assists per game. Those figures establish the level of production he recorded, while the relatively brief listed career supports the case that his NBA run was limited. NBA.com’s Brandon Roy player page.
The available record cited here does not establish a detailed injury chronology, so it would be too strong to assign a precise number of lost prime seasons or to describe a specific medical turning point. Roy ranks highly for the combination of substantial NBA production and a short career, with greater uncertainty about the exact path that was cut short.
Rank #4
4. Grant Hill: a long career shaped by a difficult comeback
Hill’s official biography describes a 19-year NBA career and frames his comeback as a response to adversity. That supports including him among major what-if careers while also recognizing that he went on to have a lengthy NBA career. Grant Hill’s official biography.
The cited biography passage does not supply a comparable statistical breakdown of Hill’s play before and after injury. As a result, this ranking does not assign him an exact number of seasons lost or claim a quantified decline. His place reflects a career interrupted and redirected, not an assertion that the rest of his NBA career did not matter.
Best Value
5. Greg Oden: a brief NBA record after being drafted first overall
Oden was the first overall pick in the 2007 NBA Draft. His NBA.com statistics page records 105 regular-season games, with career averages of 8.0 points and 6.2 rebounds. These are his NBA results, not evidence of a particular ceiling he would have reached under different circumstances. NBA.com’s Greg Oden statistics page.
Oden belongs in a what-if discussion because the contrast between a first overall selection and a short NBA record invites questions about the career that might have followed. But a draft position is not proof of future stardom, and the figures above cannot establish what his healthy-career production would have been.
Why this is a ranked five, not a top ten
“Biggest” depends on what is being measured: proven NBA excellence lost, years interrupted, or possibility never realized. A player who died before an NBA appearance cannot be compared cleanly with a former MVP whose career was disrupted after reaching the league’s peak. Nor can a short NBA statistical record by itself prove that a prospect would have become a star.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Secondary sports coverage has assembled broader what-if lists, including Sporting News’ injury-focused “What If?” team and Yahoo Sports’ ranking of what-if players. Such lists show that the debate is real; they do not create an official NBA ranking. With the documented cases above, presenting five comparatively grounded entries is more honest than filling five additional places with claims that have not been established on the same basis.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
