The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Choose a monochrome laser printer when your regular work is black text or grayscale and you have no recurring need for colour. Choose a colour laser printer when colour charts, presentations, labels, marketing documents or other colour pages are a normal part of your workload. The right choice depends on the documents you actually print, the printer’s workload rating and duplex features, and the current cost of every required cartridge—not on the purchase price or one advertised yield number alone.
What the two printer types actually do
A monochrome laser printer forms pages with black toner. It can reproduce text, lines, shading and grayscale images, but it cannot produce a coloured page. A colour laser printer normally uses separate black, cyan, magenta and yellow toner supplies to create colour as well as black and grayscale output.
That distinction matters because the extra colour capability brings more cartridges, more compatibility checks and more ways for a model’s maintenance routines to consume supplies. It does not mean every monochrome printer is cheaper to buy or run; prices and yields differ by model and region. It means you should first decide whether colour is a genuine recurring requirement, then compare the complete cost and specification of suitable models.
Start with the documents you print
Choose monochrome when black output covers the job
Monochrome is the sensible category if most pages are contracts, invoices, reports, school work, meeting notes, shipping documents, code, forms or other text-heavy material. Grayscale diagrams and photographs are acceptable when colour carries no essential meaning. You avoid paying for colour capability that sits unused and can concentrate your comparison on black-toner cost, speed, paper handling, duplexing and connectivity.
#1 Best Overall
- BEST FOR HOMES & HOME OFFICES – Engineered for consistent, premium print quality, the Brother HL-L2405W Monochrome (Black & White) Laser Printer delivers sharp, crisp prints at an affordable price. Prints one-sided documents at speeds up to 30ppm(2)
- COMPACT, CONNECTED PRINTER – Flexible connection options make this an ideal printer for home use and at-home offices. Securely connect to multiple devices with built-in dual-band wireless (2.4GHz/5GHz) or locally to a single computer via USB interface
- BROTHER MOBILE CONNECT APP – Manage your printer remotely and print from your mobile device anytime, from almost anywhere. Order Brother Genuine Supplies, track toner usage, and complete more work on-the-go(3)
- VERSATILE PAPER HANDLING – Enjoy seamless, reliable everyday printing with the 250-sheet paper tray(4) and a manual feed slot that enables printing on envelopes and specialty pape
- BROTHER IS AT YOUR SIDE – Backed by Brother with a 1-year limited warranty and free online, call, or live chat support for the life of your printer
Choose colour when colour communicates information
Colour is worth the additional supplies when you routinely print items such as charts with multiple series, annotated proofs, presentations, product sheets, classroom materials, labels or documents where colour coding is part of the message. Occasional colour pages can instead be printed by a separate service or another printer, but that only makes sense if the delay, outside cost and inconvenience are acceptable.
Do not decide from a single exceptional page
List the pages you print in a normal month and mark which ones genuinely need colour. A one-off event should not automatically move you into the colour category, while a small but weekly requirement can justify it. Also ask whether colleagues or family members will use the printer; the decision should reflect the shared workload rather than only your own documents.
Monochrome and colour laser printers compared
| Decision factor | Monochrome laser | Colour laser |
|---|---|---|
| Output | Black text and grayscale only | Black, grayscale and colour documents |
| Consumables | Usually a black toner cartridge, plus any model-specific drum, belt or waste-toner items | Black, cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges, plus any model-specific drum, belt or waste-toner items |
| Cost comparison | Compare black cartridge price divided by its declared yield, then add other required supplies | Compare black and each colour cartridge separately, then account for colour use and other required supplies |
| Yield interpretation | Use the model’s stated monochrome yield as a standardized starting point, not a promise | Use the model’s stated colour and black yields as standardized starting points, not a promise |
| Workload fit | Check rated monthly volume, speed, paper capacity and automatic duplexing for the exact model | Check the same items; do not assume an enterprise colour model suits a home office |
| Connectivity | Verify Wi‑Fi, Ethernet and mobile-printing support if required | Verify the same features; specifications vary by model |
| Maintenance behaviour | Fewer toner colours to monitor | Some models may use or rotate colour toner during initialization, cleaning, calibration or registration even when jobs are set to black and white |
This is a category comparison, not a promise that every model in one column costs less or lasts longer than every model in the other.
Recommended Free Tools
How toner yield figures should be read
ISO yields are comparison numbers
HP describes ISO/IEC 19752 for monochrome yield and ISO/IEC 19798 for colour yield in its LaserJet Page Yields guidance. The different test methods mean that a monochrome figure and a colour figure are not interchangeable predictions of your personal page count.
Rank #2
- BEST FOR SMALL BUSINESSES – Engineered for extraordinary productivity, the Brother DCP-L2640DW Monochrome (Black & White) 3-in-1 combines laser printer, scanner, copier in one compact footprint and delivers high-quality black & white prints
- FAST PRINTER WITH EFFICIENT SCANNING – Produces documents quickly with print speeds up to 36 ppm(2) and scan speeds up to 23.6/7.9 ipm(3) (black/color). A 50-page auto document feeder(4) allows for convenient, time saving multi-page scanning and copying
- FLEXIBLE CONNECTION OPTIONS – Easily navigate the changing demands of your business with secure multi-device connectivity via built-in dual-band wireless (2.4GHz / 5GHz) and Ethernet. Or connect locally to a single computer via USB interface
- BROTHER MOBILE CONNECT APP – Print, scan, and manage your wireless printer anytime, from almost anywhere from your mobile device. Order Brother Genuine Supplies, track toner usage, and complete more work on-the-go(5)
- CHOOSE BROTHER GENUINE TONER – When it’s time to replace your toner, be sure to choose Brother Genuine TN830 or TN830XL replacement toner. And with Refresh EZ Print Subscription Service, you’ll never worry about running out of toner again and you’ll enjoy savings of up to 50%(6) on Brother Genuine Toner. Get started with Refresh today with a Free Trial(1)
HP puts the limitation plainly: “Page yield data should be used as a starting point for comparison purposes, and not to predict the exact yield you will get from your HP printer and cartridge.” The same principle applies when you compare other manufacturers’ published figures.
Coverage changes the result
Brother’s support guidance lists page coverage, paper size, font size and graphics among factors that affect how long toner lasts. A page of sparse text uses much less toner than a full-page graphic, a dark background or a document with large headings. Your result will also vary with job size and operating conditions. Treat the stated yield as a standardized baseline, then adjust your budget for the content you actually print.
Introductory cartridges can be smaller
Some printers ship with introductory cartridges that yield less than the replacement cartridges. Check the box contents and the exact replacement-cartridge yields before calculating your first-year cost. Otherwise, a printer may appear inexpensive until the initial supplies run out sooner than expected.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Colour toner can be used even for black-and-white jobs
Setting a document to black and white does not guarantee that a colour laser will never use colour toner. Brother explains in its colour-toner usage guidance that some models can rotate colour cartridges during initialization, cleaning, calibration and registration. HP also notes that some printers combine toner colours to improve black output, while a supported black-only setting can use black toner alone.
Rank #3
- FAST PRINT SPEEDS: Print up to 19 pages per minute.
- COMPACT DESIGN: Space-saving, compact design fits anywhere in your home, school or small office.
- WIRELESS CONNECTIVITY: Print from almost anywhere in your workspace using your compatible mobile device.
- PAPER CAPACITY: Up to 150 sheets.
- SUSTAINABILITY: Uses less than 2 watts in Energy Saver mode.
Behaviour is model- and setting-specific. Before buying, read the exact printer’s documentation for black-only printing, cartridge requirements and maintenance cycles. If a colour cartridge is empty, the printer may stop even when you intend to print only black pages; do not assume that a monochrome driver setting overrides every hardware requirement.
Build an honest running-cost comparison
Record the same information for every candidate
- Write down the current local price of the printer, including the exact regional model number.
- Record whether the box contains standard, high-yield or introductory cartridges and the declared yield of each.
- Record the current replacement price and declared yield for black toner and, on colour models, cyan, magenta and yellow toner.
- Check for separate drum, imaging-unit, transfer-belt, waste-toner or maintenance items and record their replacement intervals and prices when the manufacturer specifies them.
- Note the warranty, regional availability and whether supplies are still listed as compatible with that model.
Calculate a rough standardized toner cost
For one cartridge, divide its current price by its declared page yield. Keep black and each colour cartridge as separate lines rather than combining them into one attractive average. This calculation is only a comparison aid: coverage, print mode, maintenance use and cartridge availability can change the amount you actually spend.
For a colour model, estimate your monthly mix separately: black-only pages, pages using light colour, and pages with heavy colour coverage. Then check whether the printer can require all cartridges for maintenance or for the selected print mode. A low nominal colour cost is not useful if your documents use one colour heavily and that cartridge needs frequent replacement.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Why a universal “mono is cheaper” number would mislead
There is no same-market, same-date price comparison here for a matched monochrome and colour pair. Printer prices, cartridge prices, regional supplies and product status change. A high-volume monochrome model can cost more upfront than a compact colour model, while a colour model’s four-cartridge set may be economical for a heavy colour workload. Make the calculation with current prices for the models you can actually buy.
Rank #4
- BEST FOR HOME OFFICES & SMALL TEAMS – Engineered for consistent, premium print quality, the Brother HL-L2460DW Monochrome (Black & White) Laser Printer produces documents that are clear, crisp, and easy to review and share, all at an affordable price
- COMPACT, CONNECTED, EXCEPTIONALLY EFFICIENT– Connect with built-in dual-band wireless (2.4GHz/5GHz), Ethernet, or to a single computer via USB interface. Prints at speeds up to 36ppm(2), plus automatic duplex printing saves time and reduces paper waste
- BROTHER MOBILE CONNECT APP – Manage your wireless printer remotely and print from your mobile device anytime, from almost anywhere. Order Brother Genuine Supplies, track toner usage, and complete more work on-the-go(3)
- VERSATILE PAPER HANDLING – Tackle high-volume black & white printing with the 250-sheet capacity paper tray.(4) The manual feed slot enables printing on envelopes and specialty paper
- BROTHER IS AT YOUR SIDE – Backed by Brother with a 1-year limited warranty and free online, call, or live chat support for the life of your printer
Published examples: useful specifications, not universal recommendations
Manufacturer examples illustrate how widely specifications can vary. They are not a current market ranking, and one cited monochrome model is explicitly discontinued.
| Example | Published figures | How to use the information |
|---|---|---|
| Brother HL‑L6400DWG monochrome laser | About 12,000 pages from the included toner; optional replacement toner up to about 20,000 pages; up to 52 pages per minute | The Brother USA page identifies this model as discontinued. Use the figures to understand a high-volume mono specification, not as a current buying recommendation. |
| Brother HL‑EX470W colour laser | 15,000 pages black and 12,000 pages for each colour cartridge; up to 42 pages per minute in simplex and duplex | This is an enterprise colour printer presented for mid- to large-sized workgroups. It is not automatically appropriate for a home office. |
| Brother TN920-series cartridge examples | About 3,000 pages for standard TN920 black, 6,000 for TN920XL, 11,000 for TN920XXL, 18,000 for TN920UXXL and 25,000 for TN925 | These are specific cartridge figures from Brother’s support guidance, not universal yields for all monochrome printers. |
Brother describes the HL‑EX470W as: “The Brother Workhorse HL‐EX470W Enterprise Color Laser Printer provides enterprise‐level performance, advanced security features, and bold color output in a compact footprint that is ideal for mid to large‐sized workgroups.” That description explains its intended segment; it does not establish that it is the right size or value for your workload.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Match the printer to your workload
Monthly volume
Check the manufacturer’s recommended monthly volume as well as its maximum duty cycle. A maximum is a stress limit, not a comfortable everyday target. Choose a model whose recommended range covers your normal months, with headroom for occasional peaks.
Speed
Compare pages per minute only after checking whether the figure applies to simplex, duplex, black, colour or a particular paper size. The HL‑EX470W example publishes up to 42 pages per minute in both simplex and duplex, while the discontinued HL‑L6400DWG example publishes up to 52 pages per minute. Those figures come from different products and should not be treated as a controlled speed test.
Automatic duplexing and paper capacity
Automatic two-sided printing can reduce paper use and manual handling for reports and drafts. Confirm that duplexing is automatic, check its supported paper sizes and weights, and verify the input-tray capacity against your normal batch size. A printer that is fast but requires frequent loading may be a poor fit for a busy office.
Connectivity and multifunction features
Check for the connections you actually need: Wi‑Fi for flexible placement, Ethernet for a shared office network, and mobile-printing support for phones and tablets. If scanning, copying or faxing is part of the requirement, compare a multifunction printer rather than assuming a print-only specification includes those functions. Confirm the exact regional model because feature sets can differ.
Quick Recap
Buy monochrome when black and grayscale output fully covers your recurring work; buy colour when colour is a regular, useful part of the document. Then compare current local prices, declared yields, maintenance supplies, workload ratings, duplexing and connectivity for the exact models available to you. Published yields—including the manufacturer examples above—are standardized starting points, not guarantees, and colour printers can have model-specific toner use even for black-and-white jobs. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
When each category is the better fit
Monochrome is usually the better fit when:
Colour is usually the better fit when:
Final buying checklist
Bottom line
