How to Choose a Metroidvania: Combat, Map Design, Difficulty, and Length

iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Choose a Metroidvania by matching four design decisions to your preferences: how demanding the combat feels, how much the map expects you to remember, which difficulty and navigation aids can be adjusted, and what “length” means for your available time. The genre label alone does not tell you whether a game is forgiving, guidance-heavy, execution-focused, or comfortable with getting lost.

A discovery-led game can be ideal if you enjoy finding your own route, while the same uncertainty can make another game feel tedious. Before buying, look for evidence about combat tools, route reconnections, map markers, adjustable parameters, and separate main-story and completion estimates.

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		Minecraft - Nintendo Switch	$29.82	Buy on Amazon

Start with a four-part decision rule

1. Decide what kind of combat you want

Ask whether ordinary encounters are mainly obstacles to avoid, timing tests built around parries and dodges, or opportunities to combine a large toolkit. “Responsive combat” describes an input and animation goal, not a guarantee that every player will find the game easy. Look for specific evidence such as parry timing controls, dodge-window options, enemy-health sliders, practice areas, or a combat system built around chaining several attack types.

2. Decide how much uncertainty you enjoy

Map design determines how much you must remember and infer. Some games provide explicit objectives, blocked-route indicators, and ways to record points of interest. Others build a dense, connected world in which detours and occasional disorientation are part of the intended experience.

#1 Best Overall

Minecraft - Nintendo Switch

• Minecraft is a game about placing blocks and going on adventures
• Explore randomly generated worlds and build amazing things from the simplest of homes to the grandest of castles
• Play in creative mode with unlimited resources or mine deep into the world in survival mode, crafting weapons and armor to fend off the dangerous mobs
• Play on the go in handheld or tabletop modes
• Includes Super Mario Mash-Up, Natural Texture Pack, Biome Settlers Skin Pack, Battle & Beasts Skin Pack, Campfire Tales Skin Pack; Compatible with Nintendo Switch only

$29.82

Buy on Amazon

3. Check which challenge and guidance settings are real

An easy, normal, and hard selector is only one form of accessibility. A game may separately change enemy damage, enemy health, parry timing, dodge windows, platforming assistance, or navigation prompts. Verify the exact feature list for your platform and version rather than assuming that the entire genre offers the same controls.

4. Define your completion target before comparing hours

“Length” can mean the critical path, the story plus side areas, or every collectible and optional challenge. Getting stuck, exploring alternate routes, and repeating bosses can change the total substantially. Compare estimates only when they identify the target, source, date, and version.

Map design: discovery-led or guided?

What a discovery-led map asks of you

Team Cherry describes Hollow Knight as a coherent, interconnected world designed around discovery, backtracking, and routes that may take players away from the obvious objective. In a 2025 interview, animator and co-director Ari Gibson said, “One of the things we were really keen on is getting as many connections between areas as we could.” The same discussion acknowledges that becoming lost can be part of the experience rather than a defect. Read the full explanation in PC Gamer’s interview with Team Cherry.

This style rewards players who enjoy forming a mental model of the world, noticing environmental clues, and returning to a remembered obstacle after gaining a new ability. It can frustrate players who want a clear next destination or who have limited time to reconstruct where a blocked passage was located. Gibson and designer William Pellen also said they largely avoided presenting the game themselves as a “Metroidvania” in marketing, a reminder that a label does not replace examining the actual map rules. Their earlier discussion of the world and its intended discovery experience appears in Nintendo Australia’s Team Cherry interview.

What guided navigation changes

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown provides a contrasting model. Ubisoft’s player guide describes Exploration and Guided modes that can be switched during play. Its map can show objective icons and indicators for available or blocked routes. That means you can retain exploratory freedom while turning on more explicit direction when you need it; the setting does not require choosing a permanent mode before starting.

The same guide describes Memory Shards, which let you pin a screenshot to the map. Senior Game Designer Rémi Boutin explains the purpose as follows: “It’s a simple idea: pin a screenshot to the map to have a simple way to remember the connection between the map and the world, and help you remember a place you want to explore at a later point.” See the feature list in Ubisoft’s The First Hours player guide.

Questions to ask before buying

• Does acquiring an ability open several older routes, or only one obvious door?
• Do shortcuts reconnect distant regions, reducing repeated travel?
• Does the map record blocked locations automatically, or must you remember them?
• Can you place custom markers or screenshots?
• Can guidance be enabled or disabled without restarting?

If you answer “yes” to the first two questions and prefer the last three features, a guided or marker-rich map is likely to fit better. If the pleasure is inferring connections and finding detours without prompts, a discovery-led map may be the better match.

Combat: execution test or improvisation toolkit?

Read the combat verbs, not just the genre label

Look for the actions you will repeat every few seconds. A game centered on precise parries and short dodge windows demands different practice from one that lets you combine ranged attacks, aerial moves, counters, and crowd-control tools. Ask whether enemies are designed to be bypassed, defeated through pattern recognition, or dismantled with a flexible loadout.

Ubisoft describes The Lost Crown as deliberately built around responsive, player-controlled combat choreography in which attacks and defensive moves can be composed from the available tools. That is a developer account of design intent, not independent testing and not a claim that every player will experience the game as easy. The combat philosophy is discussed in Ubisoft’s Accessibility Spotlight interview.

Use measured figures carefully

Ubisoft Senior Game Designer Rémi Boutin reported that nearly 20% of players who finished The Lost Crown used custom difficulty parameters, while about half completed it on the default preset. The interview does not provide a sample size or methodology, so treat these as figures reported by the developer for that game, not as a survey of Metroidvania players or evidence that a particular setting is normally required.

Combat questions that predict fit

• Can you practice parries, counters, or movement in a safe area?
• Are enemy health and damage separate settings, or locked together?
• Does the game offer alternatives when a boss pattern does not suit you?
• Are ranged, defensive, and mobility tools all useful, or is one dominant strategy expected?
• Can settings be changed after a difficult section, and do they affect rewards or endings?

Players who enjoy mastering timing should prioritize explicit defensive mechanics and demanding enemy patterns. Players who prefer experimentation should seek several viable attack and movement tools, plus settings that reduce punishment without removing the entire combat system.

Difficulty and accessibility: inspect the individual controls

The Lost Crown’s layered approach

The Lost Crown’s player guide lists four combat presets: Rookie, Warrior, Hero, and Immortal. It also lists separately adjustable parameters, including enemy health, enemy damage, parry timing, and dodge windows. This distinction matters: a player can preserve a preferred damage level while making a timing window more forgiving, instead of moving every aspect to an easier preset.

The guide additionally identifies guided objective icons, map screenshots, a practice area, and an optional portal that bypasses difficult platforming sections on the main path. These are specific features of The Lost Crown; confirm that they are present on your platform and current version before relying on them. Boutin summarized the design principle in the sentence, “Accessibility and challenge are not necessarily antagonistic concepts!”

Why one difficulty rating is misleading

A game may have forgiving combat but demanding platforming, or clear navigation but bosses that require long pattern-learning sessions. Alternate routes can let you postpone a difficult room, while an optional assistance feature can remove a single barrier without reducing every encounter. Therefore, ask for separate information about boss difficulty, ordinary enemies, platforming, and navigation rather than accepting a single “easy” or “hard” label.

Build a settings checklist

• Timing: Can parry and dodge windows be widened?
• Punishment: Can enemy damage be reduced independently of enemy health?
• Repetition: Is there a practice or training area?
• Traversal: Is there assistance for precision platforming?
• Navigation: Can objective prompts and route indicators be toggled?
• Persistence: Do changes apply immediately, and can they be reversed?

Length: compare completion targets, not headline hours

Three useful definitions of “how long to beat”

1. Main path: The time to reach the ending while doing only the progression required to finish.
2. Story plus extras: The main path with selected side quests, upgrades, and optional regions.
3. Completionist: Collectibles, optional bosses, alternate objectives, and repeated attempts until the checklist is complete.

When a source gives only one number, you cannot know which of these it represents. Platform, patch, route choice, time spent stuck, and familiarity with action games also affect the result. A completionist total is not a promise that every player needs that many hours, and a main-story total is not a ceiling on exploration.

A scope example, not a genre benchmark

In a Bandai Namco developer interview, the director of Shadow Labyrinth said the project was initially expected to take 20–30 hours and that his own final-stage playthrough took about 60 hours after the scope expanded. The page does not display a publication date, and the figure is the director’s experience rather than a player average. Read the context in Bandai Namco’s developer interview. It illustrates why an early estimate and a later personal completion time should never be presented as a universal expectation.

Use source details when comparing

For each game, record who supplied the estimate, when it was published, the platform or version, and the completion target. This research did not establish an apples-to-apples playtime table for leading Metroidvanias, so a precise cross-game ranking would be invented rather than informative.

How the named examples fit different players

A practical buying workflow

1. Write your non-negotiables. For example: adjustable dodge timing, no mandatory precision platforming, or a main path that fits a weekend.
2. Classify the map. Decide whether you want objective-led navigation, optional guidance, or a world that expects you to get lost and return later.
3. Inspect combat details. Find out whether the game emphasizes parries, dodge timing, broad move combinations, ranged tools, or bypassing enemies.
4. Check the settings menu documentation. Look for independent controls rather than relying on an easy/normal/hard label.
5. Separate your time budget. Record main story, story-plus-extras, and completionist estimates as different targets; mark any estimate that lacks a source or date.
6. Choose the uncertainty you actually enjoy. If you like drawing your own conclusions from the environment, accept less guidance. If losing track of a route would make you quit, prioritize markers, screenshots, and explicit objective icons.

Common mistakes when choosing

Treating “Metroidvania” as a difficulty rating

The label describes a family of exploration and ability-gated structures, not a fixed combat standard. Two games can share the genre while differing sharply in parry demands, platforming precision, boss endurance, and navigation support.

Assuming accessibility removes all challenge

Granular settings can target one barrier while leaving the rest of the game intact. A wider dodge window does not automatically simplify route planning, and a guided map does not make a boss pattern disappear.

Buying from a single playtime number

A number without a completion target can understate an exploration-heavy run or overstate a focused story run. Treat creator estimates as context, not guarantees, and do not convert one developer’s personal time into a genre average.

Ignoring the map until you are stuck

If remembering blocked routes is a concern, check in advance whether the game records them, allows custom markers, or stores screenshots. Navigation friction is a core design choice, not a minor interface detail.

The bottom line

Choose a Metroidvania by the experience you want to repeat: discovery or direction, execution or improvisation, fixed challenge or adjustable parameters, and a focused story or broad completion. Hollow Knight is a useful example of discovery-led interconnected mapping; The Lost Crown shows how explicit guidance and granular settings can coexist with demanding action design. Use those contrasts as questions to ask about any game, not as a universal ranking.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

Minecraft - Nintendo Switch

Minecraft is a game about placing blocks and going on adventures; Play on the go in handheld or tabletop modes

$29.82

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.