iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
No. You can start with Tormented Souls 2 and follow its basic story without finishing the original. However, the sequel continues Caroline Walker’s story, so playing Tormented Souls first gives you more context for the characters, lore and emotional stakes. If you want to begin with the sequel, use the official story recap highlighted on the game’s Steam community page.
What the short answer means
Tormented Souls 2 is designed as a continuation rather than a completely unrelated entry. Caroline Walker returns, and the sequel takes place months after the events of the first game. That timing lets the new game move forward with an established protagonist and history instead of introducing Caroline from scratch.
Even so, the available review evidence indicates that the sequel remains independently playable. A Steam review says players do not necessarily need to have played the first game to follow what is happening, while also noting that prior experience provides more context. Meristation likewise describes the second game as taking place months after the original and says it can be enjoyed on its own.
In practical terms, there are two different standards for “understanding” a sequel:
#1 Best Overall
- Take on the role of the Herald, Pyromancer, or Warrior as you navigate the haunted ruins of The Sunless City. Your ultimate challenge?
- A brutal battle against the formidable Dragon Slayer Ornstein and the fearsome Executioner Smough.
- 1-3 players
- 100 minutes + play time
- Ages: 14+
- Basic comprehension: knowing what Caroline is doing in the sequel and following its immediate plot. You can reach this level without the first game.
- Full continuity: recognizing the significance of returning characters, understanding references to earlier events and feeling the weight of Caroline’s past. The original is the better preparation for this experience.
Therefore, skipping the first game is a reasonable choice for a gameplay-first player, but it is not the ideal order for someone who cares most about story continuity.
How the two games are connected
Caroline Walker is the continuity anchor
The official description of Tormented Souls 2 presents it as the sequel in which Caroline Walker returns. That wording matters: the second game is not merely using the same title or setting. It follows the same central character after the first game’s events.
Because Caroline’s history carries into the sequel, the original can explain why she is in her new situation, what she has already endured and why certain developments matter to her. A newcomer can still learn the immediate information needed to proceed, but that information may feel more like background exposition than lived history.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
The sequel begins after the first game
Meristation’s review places the sequel months after the events of the original. This gap creates some narrative distance: the second game is not presented as a scene-by-scene continuation that assumes you remember the previous game’s final moments. At the same time, the events of the first game remain part of Caroline’s established story.
That is why the sequel can be both accessible and richer in sequence. The time jump gives new players room to enter the story, while returning players can interpret the new circumstances through what they already know.
An official recap is available
The official Steam community page published a recap of the first game’s story for players who had completed it. That recap is also the most useful bridge for someone who wants to start with Tormented Souls 2 without playing the original immediately.
A recap cannot reproduce every discovery or emotional beat from playing the first game yourself. It can, however, supply the essential chain of events and reduce the chance that you will mistake a returning element for a brand-new one. Read it before launching the sequel if you want a middle ground between playing both games in order and going in completely cold.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →What you may miss by skipping the original
Story context
The clearest cost is context. Reviews of the sequel warn that newcomers may have difficulty getting fully up to speed with its lore. A PlayStation Store review recommends playing the first game to avoid missing story material.
This does not mean that the sequel becomes unintelligible. It means that some information may arrive without the same foundation that a returning player has. You may understand what a character says while lacking the history behind the statement, or recognize that an event is important without knowing why it carries emotional weight.
Emotional continuity
Playing the original lets you experience Caroline’s earlier ordeal rather than receiving it as a summary. When the sequel refers back to that history, the reference can function as a continuation of a personal journey. If you skip the first game, the same moment may still be clear at a plot level but less meaningful emotionally.
This difference is especially relevant to players who treat horror games as narrative experiences. Atmosphere, revelations and character reactions are easier to appreciate when you know what has already happened. If your priority is simply reaching the sequel’s new situations, that benefit may not justify the extra game.
Earlier lore and references
The first game establishes the fictional background that the sequel builds on. The sequel’s recap exists because those earlier events matter enough to summarize. Reading it should cover the broad outline, but it will not give you the same familiarity with every place, person or reveal that comes from playing through the original.
Skipping also creates a spoiler trade-off. A recap necessarily reveals major events from the first game. If you might play the original later and want its discoveries to remain surprises, avoid the recap and play the first game before starting the sequel. If you have already decided that you will not play the original, the recap is the most efficient way to reduce confusion.
Can you start with Tormented Souls 2?
Yes. The evidence from the Steam review and Meristation supports starting with the sequel, provided you accept that some background will be less familiar. Use the following approach to make that order work:
- Decide how much of the first game you want spoiled. If you may play it later, do not read a detailed plot summary. If you are choosing the sequel permanently, continue to the official recap.
- Read the official Steam community recap. It was published specifically to help players who needed a refresher on the first game’s story.
- Start the sequel and treat unexplained history as intentional backstory. You do not need to stop at every unfamiliar reference. The sequel is structured to move its own story forward.
- Keep the original as an optional follow-up. If the sequel makes Caroline’s past especially interesting, you can return to the first game later, knowing that some of its major developments may already be spoiled.
This order is most suitable when you are primarily interested in the sequel’s gameplay, setting or immediate plot and do not want to delay starting it.
Recommended Free Tools
Which play order fits your priorities?
| Play order | Story context | Time commitment | Spoiler exposure | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original, then sequel | Most complete; you experience Caroline’s history directly. | Requires both games; no playtime figure is established in the available material. | Preserves the first game’s discoveries until you reach them naturally. | Story-first players and anyone who wants full emotional continuity. |
| Official recap, then sequel | Provides the key background in condensed form. | Lower commitment than playing both games; the recap’s reading length is not stated. | Reveals major first-game events. | Newcomers who want context without completing the original first. |
| Sequel with no preparation | You can follow the immediate story, but some lore and references may have less context. | Lets you begin the sequel immediately. | Leaves the original’s story less explicitly spoiled at the outset, although the sequel may still refer to earlier events. | Gameplay-first players who prefer to discover the sequel on their own terms. |
| Sequel first, original later | The sequel comes first, so earlier events may be understood retrospectively. | Spreads the two games across separate sessions. | Expect the sequel to reveal or summarize some elements from the original. | Players who want to start now but remain open to exploring Caroline’s past afterward. |
Who should play Tormented Souls first?
Choose the original first if story is your main reason for playing
Play in release order if you want to understand Caroline’s development from its beginning, absorb the lore without a condensed explanation and recognize the significance of returning elements. This is also the safest choice if you dislike entering a story after its protagonist has already gone through major events.
The PlayStation Store review’s recommendation reflects this concern: skipping the first game can mean missing story material. Playing it first removes the need to reconstruct that material from a recap or scattered references.
Choose the original first if you avoid spoilers
The official recap is useful, but its purpose is to tell you what happened previously. If preserving the original game’s reveals matters to you, play it before reading any summary and before starting the sequel. Starting with the sequel may expose you to information about the first game that cannot be taken back.
Choose the original first if you want the strongest emotional payoff
A direct continuation has more impact when you have personally experienced the events being continued. Caroline’s reactions and the sequel’s references can still work for a newcomer, but the original gives those moments a fuller personal history.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Who can safely start with Tormented Souls 2?
Gameplay-first players
If your priority is playing the newest entry rather than completing a narrative in order, start with Tormented Souls 2. The Steam review’s assessment supports this approach: prior knowledge adds context, but it is not presented as an absolute requirement for following the sequel.
Players who are undecided about the original
Starting with the sequel lets you test whether Caroline’s story and the series’ style appeal to you. If they do, you can decide later whether to play the original for additional background. Go in expecting retrospective spoilers rather than a spoiler-free introduction to the first game.
Rank #4
- Package Dimensions: 30.5 H x 8.9 L x 24.4 W (centimetres)
- Number of players: 1-4
- Package Weight: 0.615 kilograms
- Country of Origin : China
Players who do not mind entering an established story
Some players are comfortable joining a series midway, especially when a sequel provides its own immediate setup. The months-long gap between the games also gives the sequel a natural point of entry, even though it remains connected to the original.
Common questions about the order
Is Tormented Souls 2 a direct sequel?
Yes. It continues Caroline Walker’s story and is set months after the first game’s events. It is not a wholly separate story that only shares a name.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteWill Tormented Souls 2 make sense if I have never played the first game?
You should be able to follow the sequel at a basic level. The available Steam review says the first game is not strictly necessary, while noting that it supplies additional context. Expect some lore and character history to be less immediate.
Will I miss important story if I skip the first game?
You may miss context and some story material tied to Caroline’s earlier experiences. The PlayStation Store review specifically recommends the original to avoid that gap. The official recap is the practical alternative if you do not want to play the first game yet.
Should I read the recap before or after starting the sequel?
Read it before starting if you want the clearest possible background. Skip it until later only if you want to protect the first game’s major surprises and are comfortable with a less complete understanding of the continuity at the beginning.
Is there a single correct order?
No. Release order is the strongest choice for a story-focused playthrough, while recap-then-sequel and sequel-first are valid for players who value immediacy or gameplay more than complete narrative context.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Bottom line for new players
Start with Tormented Souls if you want the fullest version of Caroline Walker’s story and do not want to miss the setup behind the sequel. Start with Tormented Souls 2 if you mainly want to play the newer game; read the official Steam community recap first when you want essential context without committing to the original.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
