Best Games Like Silent Hill and The Exorcist for Supernatural Psychological Horror

iTechGuides is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Start with Silent Hill 2 (2024 remake). It is the closest modern match for guilt-driven psychological horror: the town’s fog, creatures and puzzles externalize a protagonist’s despair and trauma instead of treating horror as a sequence of jump scares. If your reference point is The Exorcist and you want explicit spirits, choose Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly. For a realistic haunted house, play Visage; for supernatural investigation that bends reality, choose Alan Wake 2; for helpless, resource-starved survival, choose Amnesia: The Bunker; and for a combat-heavy cult story, choose the Resident Evil 4 remake.

The recommendations below separate symbolic psychological horror from ghost stories, possession-adjacent dread, action, and pure survival tension, so you can pick the experience you actually want rather than simply another game labeled “horror.”

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		Silent Hill 2 (PS5)	$29.50	Buy on Amazon
2		Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5	$15.19	Buy on Amazon
3		Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5	$39.88	Buy on Amazon

Quick comparison: which game fits your kind of horror?

Platform catalogs, regional editions and storefront status can change. Treat the platform column as a starting point and confirm the current listing before buying.

What “psychological horror” means in these games

Psychological horror is not simply horror with a dark story. The PlayStation editorial guide describes it as a form in which “the barrier between madness and reality blurs.” The fear comes from uncertainty about perception, memory, guilt or identity, not only from an enemy’s attack pattern.

#1 Best Overall

Silent Hill 2 (PS5)

• Fully Remade to terrify modern audiences
• KONAMI's intense psychological horror masterpiece SILENT HILL 2 is made exclusively for PlayStation 5
• The main protagonist James Sunderland searches for clues in the namesake town, after receiving a mysterious letter from his wife Mary… who has long been dead
• Experience the eerie monsters and other manifestations of James' consciousness reworked after 20 years
• Made with state-of-the-art technology to play on modern entertainment systems in 4K

$29.50

Buy on Amazon

That distinction explains why these recommendations feel different. Silent Hill 2 turns one character’s guilt into a physical landscape. Alan Wake 2 asks whether a story can rewrite the world. Visage makes an ordinary home feel untrustworthy. Fatal Frame II presents ghosts and ritual directly, while Amnesia: The Bunker makes every decision a calculation about light, ammunition and escape. Resident Evil 4 uses supernatural and cult elements but channels them through confident action.

The best overall match: Silent Hill 2 (2024 remake)

If you want one answer to “What should I play after Silent Hill?” choose the 2024 remake of Silent Hill 2. GameSpot’s description centers on the protagonist’s guilt and despair, with personal trauma made literal through monsters. That is the series’ defining idea: enemies, locations and recurring images carry emotional meaning, so progress is also an attempt to understand what happened.

Why it matches the request

• Psychological weight: The horror is tied to remorse, denial and grief rather than an interchangeable supernatural threat.
• Atmosphere: Fog, ruined spaces and uncertain visibility create tension before an enemy appears.
• Survival-horror structure: Exploration and problem solving matter as much as combat, preserving the stop-start rhythm associated with classic psychological horror.
• Third-person readability: You can study the protagonist and environment, which supports visual symbolism without turning the game into a detached walking tour.

Who should choose something else

This is not the best choice if your priority is a first-person haunted house, constant ghost encounters or brisk action. Its monsters and supernatural events are meaningful partly because the game withholds simple explanations. Players looking for explicit possession-style imagery may find Fatal Frame II more direct; players wanting firearms and melee momentum should move to Resident Evil 4.

For a supernatural mystery that destabilizes reality: Alan Wake 2

Alan Wake 2 is the strongest alternative when “like Silent Hill” means a story in which reality itself cannot be trusted. GameSpot describes two playable perspectives: troubled writer Alan Wake and FBI agent Saga Anderson. Their investigation unfolds as a supernatural mystery that blurs fiction and reality.

What the investigation changes

Instead of navigating one symbolic town, you follow two connected lines of inquiry. The writer’s perspective leans into constructed narrative and uncertainty; the agent’s perspective gives the mystery an investigative frame. This structure makes the game more story-forward than maze-like survival horror.

Best for

• Players who want a supernatural case to solve rather than a purely haunted location.
• Readers of horror who enjoy unreliable reality, authorship and stories that comment on their own construction.
• Players comfortable with a stronger action-investigation balance than Silent Hill 2.

Choose it when the phrase “psychological horror” makes you think of unstable reality and narrative puzzles. Choose Visage instead when you want the physical spaces of one house to do most of the frightening.

For a realistic haunted house: Visage

Visage is the clearest first-person answer for domestic haunting. TechRadar describes a huge, terrifying house filled with the memories of the dead families who lived there. The setting is not a brief stage between levels; it is the central source of disorientation, investigation and dread.

Why the house works as horror

A familiar floor plan becomes threatening because rooms, objects and memories cannot be treated as neutral scenery. The realism makes every change in lighting, sound or arrangement feel personal. You are not touring a fantasy castle; you are trying to understand a home that has absorbed several tragedies.

Rank #2

Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5

• TERRIFYING ZOMBIES WAITING AROUND EVERY CORNER -- Driven by insatiable hunger, these creatures act on instinct, gnashing their teeth, ripping at flesh, and devouring their victims. The new immersive camera lets you feel their fangs as they sink into your flesh.
• RACCOON CITY, REBUILT IN INTRICATE DETAIL -- The characters, environments, and story have all been rebuilt from the ground up to create a terrifying world that feels both nostalgic and new.
• NEW FOR PLAYSTATION5 – Upgraded features new to the PlayStation5 version of the game include a higher frame rate, 3D audio, added ray tracing, and engaging DualSense support for Haptic Feedback and Adaptive Triggers.

$15.19

Buy on Amazon

Trade-offs

• Atmosphere over combat: The appeal is tension, observation and survival, not a large arsenal.
• First-person intensity: The viewpoint keeps threats close and limits your ability to read the character’s reactions from outside.
• Exploration commitment: The large house rewards patient searching, but players who prefer tightly directed levels may find its navigation demanding.

Pick Visage when your mental image of The Exorcist is a home becoming spiritually unsafe. Pick Fatal Frame II when you want ghosts to appear as explicit, named supernatural opponents.

For explicit ghosts and ritualized spirit encounters: Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly is the most direct recommendation for readers whose reference point is possession, apparitions and ritual dread. PlayStation describes a sinister village populated by vengeful spirits. The defining tool is the Camera Obscura, which players use to repel, capture and seal away spirits.

How the Camera Obscura changes combat

The camera turns looking at a ghost into the defensive action. You must face the apparition rather than simply fire past it, so every encounter combines vulnerability with recognition. That mechanic supports the game’s central supernatural idea: the dead are not abstract damage sources but entities that must be confronted and contained.

Why it is not simply another Silent Hill

Silent Hill 2 uses monsters as extensions of a character’s inner life. Fatal Frame II puts folklore, spirits and ritual at the center. Its fear is more openly paranormal, making it a better fit for an Exorcist-style request, even when its psychological symbolism is less dominant.

• Choose it for ghost visibility, haunted-village atmosphere and ritual mechanics.
• Expect a more focused spirit-horror identity than a broad mystery about guilt.
• Confirm the current edition and platform listing, since availability can vary by release.

For maximum vulnerability and resource pressure: Amnesia: The Bunker

Amnesia: The Bunker strips survival horror down to isolation and improvisation. PlayStation’s description places a lone French soldier in a desolate World War I bunker with one bullet remaining. The threat adapts, the environment is semi-open, and a hidden nightmare controls the pace.

What the scarcity does to your decisions

One bullet is not a combat strategy; it is an emergency option. You must decide whether a noise warrants investigation, whether a route is safe enough to reuse and whether a resource should be spent now or saved for a worse moment. That pressure creates psychological horror through anticipation rather than elaborate symbolism.

Best fit and limitations

• Best fit: Players who want evasion, experimentation and the fear of being under-equipped.
• Different from Silent Hill 2: The bunker’s terror is immediate and systemic, while Silent Hill 2 builds meaning around character guilt and trauma.
• Different from The Exorcist: The supernatural presence is a hidden nightmare rather than a conventional possession narrative.

Choose it when “psychological” means panic under pressure. Do not choose it expecting a long, symbolic character drama.

For cult horror and action: Resident Evil 4 (2023 remake)

The 2023 Resident Evil 4 remake is the action route through this recommendation list. GameSpot describes a cult, a mind-controlling parasite, firearms and melee combat. Those ingredients overlap with occult and possession-adjacent horror, but the game’s design emphasizes capability, momentum and set-piece escalation.

Rank #3

Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5

• Solve a Deadly Mystery: What begins as a small-town murder investigation rapidly spirals into a nightmare journey. Uncover the source of the supernatural darkness in this psychological horror story filled with intense suspense and unexpected twists.
• Play As Two Characters: Experience both Alan Wake’s and Saga Anderson’s stories and see events unfold from different perspectives. Switch between Anderson’s life-or-death race to solve the case and Wake’s desperate attempts to rewrite his reality to escape the depths of the Dark Place.
• Explore Two Worlds: Experience two beautiful yet terrifying worlds, each with its own rich cast of characters and deadly threats. Discover majestic landscapes of Cauldron Lake in the Pacific Northwest and the idyllic towns of Bright Falls and Watery. Contrasting sharply, attempt to escape the nightmarish cityscape of the Dark Place.
• Survive With Light: With limited resources, take on powerful supernatural enemies in desperate close-combat situations. It takes more than just a gun to survive: light is the ultimate weapon in the fight against the darkness and will be your refuge when enemies threaten to overwhelm you.
• The physical version of Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition includes the following: ● Alan Wake 2 physical game. ● The Night Springs and Lake House expansions. ● Deluxe Edition cosmetics and items: Nordic Shotgun Skin for Saga, Crimson Windbreaker for Saga, Celebrity Suit for Alan, Parliament Shotgun Skin for Alan, and Lantern Charm for Saga. ● Alan Wake Remastered (Digital Edition - included as a gift with purchase DLC on a voucher).

$39.88

Buy on Amazon

Where it overlaps with the request

• Cult setting: Organized religious extremism supplies the story’s threat and imagery.
• Loss of control: The parasite introduces bodily and mental influence, echoing possession themes without reproducing a traditional exorcism story.
• Combat variety: Gunplay and close-quarters attacks let you respond actively instead of only hiding.

Where it diverges

Its horror is less psychologically intimate than Silent Hill 2. The player is generally equipped to fight, and the pacing favors encounters and forward motion. Select it if you want supernatural-adjacent themes with polished action; select Visage or Amnesia: The Bunker if helplessness matters more than firepower.

Also consider these narrower matches

Until Dawn (2024)

The enhanced version on PS5 and PC makes player decisions determine which of eight trapped friends survive, according to PlayStation. It is cinematic, branching slasher horror rather than a close Silent Hill equivalent. Choose it for consequence-driven group drama and replayable decisions, not for symbolic fog or a solitary haunted-house investigation.

Luto

PlayStation describes a troubled artist trapped in a shifting home labyrinth, with despair, loss, anxiety, puzzles and unsettling spirits. It belongs on a shortlist for players who want a compact, inward-looking experience where the house reflects emotional distress. Its focus is closer to an artful psychological vignette than to a long survival-horror campaign.

Silent Hill: Townfall

PlayStation lists this first-person psychological-horror entry in the isolated Scottish town of St. Amelia. Fog, monsters and CRTV signals shape exploration. It is the obvious same-universe option for fans who want another Silent Hill interpretation, but verify release and storefront status before purchase because the listing may change.

The Sinking City 2

PlayStation describes a supernatural flood, eldritch horrors, ritual clues, journals and masks in a 1920s Arkham-like port city. Choose it when you want investigative occult horror with a broader setting than one haunted house. Verify release and platform status before purchase.

Silent Hill f

PC Gamer lists the 2025 entry from NeoBards as a new direction for the series. It is a same-franchise choice rather than an outside substitute, so it suits readers who want to stay within Silent Hill while trying a different setting and tone.

Mouthwashing

TechRadar highlights surreal, disturbing visuals, a non-linear narrative, difficult themes and a short experience with lasting psychological impact. It is thematically intense but not a supernatural Exorcist analogue. Choose it for disturbing character drama and narrative dislocation.

Still Wakes the Deep

TechRadar describes a narrative-led survival-horror game on a 1970s North Sea oil rig where a strange entity stalks the corridors. It is an excellent atmosphere pick if you want a confined workplace and relentless pursuit, but its setting and threat differ sharply from cults, ghosts and guilt.

Choose by the feeling you want

1. Want guilt, grief and monsters that mean something? Start with Silent Hill 2.
2. Want a supernatural investigation that questions reality? Choose Alan Wake 2.
3. Want to be trapped in a believable, memory-filled home? Choose Visage.
4. Want visible ghosts and a ritual tool for confronting them? Choose Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly.
5. Want to feel under-equipped every minute? Choose Amnesia: The Bunker.
6. Want cult imagery with substantial shooting and melee combat? Choose Resident Evil 4 (2023).
7. Want a branching cinematic slasher? Choose Until Dawn (2024).
8. Want a short, surreal psychological hit? Choose Mouthwashing or Luto, depending on whether you prefer a non-linear narrative or a haunted-home labyrinth.

Buying and setup checks before you start

• Confirm the exact edition: Remakes, enhanced releases and same-title originals can have different platform listings and content.
• Check your hardware generation: The cited listings distinguish PS5, Xbox Series X|S, PC and Nintendo Switch; do not assume a last-generation version exists.
• Review regional storefront details: Availability, language options, age ratings and prices can change by country.
• Use headphones if you can: These games rely heavily on environmental sound, distant movement and changes in domestic or industrial ambience.
• Decide your tolerance for combat: Starting with Resident Evil 4 when you wanted helplessness, or with Amnesia: The Bunker when you wanted constant action, creates the wrong first impression of the genre.

For most readers, the best first purchase is Silent Hill 2 on PS5 or PC because it unites symbolic psychological horror, exploration and supernatural atmosphere. Move to Fatal Frame II for explicit spirits, Visage for a haunted home, Alan Wake 2 for reality-bending investigation, Amnesia: The Bunker for scarcity, or Resident Evil 4 for combat.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

Silent Hill 2 (PS5)

Fully Remade to terrify modern audiences; Made with state-of-the-art technology to play on modern entertainment systems in 4K

$29.50

Bestseller No. 2

Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5

$15.19

Bestseller No. 3

Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5

$39.88

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.